The No.1 Website for Pro Audio
 Search This Thread  Search This Forum  Search Reviews  Search Gear Database  Search Gear for sale  Search Gearslutz Go Advanced
Increasing depth perception/immersion in Binaural audio? Condenser Microphones
Old 16th January 2018
Gear Addict
Oop's Avatar

Thread Starter
Increasing depth perception/immersion in Binaural audio?

Hi guys,

I just recently started exploring binaural/ambisonic audio mixing for VR and have a few questions regarding the platform.

I've been using Reaper and after exploring all the plugin options, I've been testing out AudioEase's 360pan (I like the embedded grid and pucks on the video) and the dearVR 360 plugin.

After working on a few post-production demos for a client of mine, I realised I was having a difficult time with the front-back movement perception. Sounds panned to the back, very rarely sound correctly placed. From watching videos on Youtube I realised, only recordings done with binaural microphones had that immersive depth, especially ones with the ambiences being recorded in 360. A lot of other audio I heard was quite flat and 2D, more like slightly enhanced stereo.

In my experience, dearVR's plugin had a bit more depth in panning back than the AudioEase plugin, but I wasn't too happy with some level/sound changes it applied.

Anyways, after showcasing the demo to my clients, I was sent an audio clip as reference, found in this link:

I was quite blown away by the immersion it provided. The depth, the ambience, distance information, all seemed very 3D. The Youtube version seems slightly degraded compared to what I was sent, but you can hear the sounds at the back, especially distance information.

A bit of research showed that it used something known as the 'Cetera Algorithm', used in hearing aids. I'm not sure if QSound Labs developed it, but it also seems like the technology is a decade or more old. It seems to handle audio at the back of your head quite well. In fact, the processing seems to add a kind of reverberation, so not sure how sounds directly in front of you would sound.

I was wondering if anyone had tips on how to create this level of immersion in post production within a DAW, using standard mono/stereo files, mixing in VR. I even looked around for binaural recordings of ambiences to use as a base layer, but didn't find much. Automating reverb etc. didn't really give the effect I was looking for.

TLDR:How to increase depth perception in binaural audio, similar to the link posted.
Old 2 weeks ago
Gear Addict
how were the sounds recorded that you are mixing?

in my experience, mics that have their capsules very near together (such as the neuheiser ambeo vr) provide not enough spatial information for mixes that require very large depth or movement.

yet you may use the same techniques as when 'expanding' from stereo to pseudo surround: use different reverbs for front and rear.
Old 2 weeks ago
Here for the gear
allengriswald's Avatar

I think it sounded quite flat with some stereo panning. To get depth you have to have dynamic range. Before the digital destruction of quality of sound, before those record producers destroyed the music to over compress for the cheap consumer gear, We actually had something called dynamic range. Please discover this again.
Old 2 weeks ago
Gear Head
nonnaci's Avatar

Good sound depth in the far-field is about having the direct sound-source sit with the early reflections and late reverb in a spatialized environment (see our Zephyr plugin demos and sound-samples).

For near-field type depths, the direct-source dominates and requires additional modeling of low-frequencies diffracting around the head, perturbing the HRTFs; see Muze plugin.
Old 1 week ago
Here for the gear
johannburkard's Avatar
Originally Posted by Oop View Post
[I]I was wondering if anyone had tips on how to create this level of immersion in post production within a DAW, using standard mono/stereo files, mixing in VR.
Roland RSS or Prosoniq Ambisone. Supposedly there's a different algorithm of RSS in the Roland Integra 7.
Old 1 week ago
As you suggested, the best way is with original binaural, or surround, audio files. You should also investigate using surround plug-ins, especially reverb.

Spatial placement gets freakishly esoteric when it comes to binaural and surround microphones, and I haven't heard a plug in that can accurately duplicate all the space that is created by a good surround or binaural microphone. (The digital haircut would be easy with a binaural mic.) I have also noticed height information in some of my binaural studio recordings which was very interesting - we positioned the head a little low in the room relative to the surround speakers and it was obvious in the binaural mix.

So FWIW, here's a no-plug-ins example of a recording that used a Holophonic microphone to record the voices, and a Neumann KU100 binaural microphone to capture the final binaural mixdown from the original surround mix in-studio:

Mentioned Products
Post Reply

Welcome to the Gearslutz Pro Audio Community!

Registration benefits include:
  • The ability to reply to and create new discussions
  • Access to members-only giveaways & competitions
  • Interact with VIP industry experts in our guest Q&As
  • Access to members-only sub forum discussions
  • Access to members-only Chat Room
  • Get INSTANT ACCESS to the world's best private pro audio Classifieds for only USD $20/year
  • Promote your eBay auctions and listings for free
  • Remove this message!
You need an account to post a reply. Create a username and password below and an account will be created and your post entered.

Slide to join now Processing…
Thread Tools
Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Forum Jump
Forum Jump