Make life easy for yourself. Get the band setup in the space, isolate the amps and get good drum sounds. Record everything right off the bat, drums, bass, guitars, keys, and scratch vocals. A great cue mix is very important, make sure you can hear what you're sending the band so you can dial in exactly what they want. Force the band to give you good takes, don't settle for any half-assed attempts that they'll ask you to fix later. If the first playback doesn't move you, then no amount of overdubbing will help. Manipulate them, motivate them, mock them, whatever it takes. Just make sure you're always recording..
Z