Quote:
Originally Posted by
wagtunes
Well, two people hear it so I guess we're both idiots.
Whatever. Not important enough to argue about.
(i) No one's calling anyone an "idiot". (But two people have indeed been known to be wrong before.)
(ii) "Whatever. Not important enough to argue about" after saying "I guess we're both idiots" IS arguing about it - it's just trying to have the last word is all!
(ii) Remember when I listened to your version of 'New Song', and pointed out that part of the main riff was out by 1/16th note? Your immediate reactions was to say you didn't "hear it" and you liked it the way it was; 10 minutes later, you realised I was right - and had the grace to admit it and fix your MIDI programming. At some point, I can but hope your first reaction if I comment on something like timing will be to say "hmm, Owen's usually right about these things" rather than "I guess we're both idiots".
(iii) Attached is the first verse and chorus of the song, with a straight 1-bar, 4/4 MIDI loop underneath it - long hat on beat 1, closed hats on 2, 3, 4. The song is, as I said, a straight 4/4 throughout, with no extra beats or odd time signatures, but with a couple fairly pronounced human drummer timing instances - a rush here, a drag there. You'll notice that while the timing of the click is not millisecond perfect, that it's clear that the song is in 4/4 throughout.