View Single Post
Old 20th January 2019
  #1723
Lives for gear
 
Analogue Mastering's Avatar
 

No, the sum of DAC and ADC could be both additive or compensating on certain frequencies. The point is YOU don’t know, WHAT is causing the depth. 1 person could have the match in heaven, but the worst result because he has a fridge humming on the same power group. Who knows? That’s why this test is completely useless.
Quote:
Originally Posted by capn357 View Post
You seem to be implying that both the DAC and ADC could be "off", but that one could compensate for the other thereby rendering the results of testing the pair invalid. I find it extremely unlikely that that would happen over the course of the entire 2 minute sound file.

Moreover, if a pair in Didier's list produces a file that when subtracted from the original produces a result with a 70 dB RMS difference, I would confidently state that both the DAC and ADC in that pair are excellent individual components (at least in terms transparency) and I defy you to state otherwise.

Let me guess.... you own some equipment that is included in Didier's list that isn't ranked very highly.