I'm using an old Steinway M. It sounds very beautiful but the action is a little worn and there is some noise from the hammer mechanism on a few of the bass notes. You can only hear it from the player's position but it would be picked up by a close mic. Can this type of sound be removed later with Sonic No-Noise or a similar program without too much degradation of tone quality? And if I position the mic so that the "deaf" side is facing the noise source would that possibly result in minimizing those noises sufficiently?
Yeah... some actual repair that stopped the noise from happening would seem like the best solution, even some improvisation that buffered the noisy bits from hitting each other... trying to "filter" that kind of thing after the fact, who knows....
You're in NYC . . . if it's for a big recording why not get a Steinway/other good piano tech to come have a look? Better to cure the problem than the symptoms!
I'm fortunate that we get Steinway guys in a couple times a year to service the innards of the two Steinway Ds in the hall - as well as a tuner coming down every couple of weeks. At the Bridgewater Hall (concert hall down the road, 4000 seats) they have a choice of pianos (3 or 4 I think), and for big concerts they get a tech in to set the action as the soloist requires.
If it's for a record that's going to make money, why not spend some money and get it right? Nothing worse than regretting skimping on the 'perfect' recording!
As has been said - better to solve the problem acoustically but if its on the recording already a Spectral Editor like ReNovator or Retouch can work wonders. You'd have to work on each instance individually but it has the capacity to remove the noise without any artifacts.
There are versions built into some inexpensive programs like Adobe Audition but I haven't used them and don't know how flexible the parameters are for noises like that.
granted my personal expertise runs more towards the electronic... but i've used it before on wooden actions on keyboards before with no ill effects... also when i rebuilt an old starck grand (30 yrs ago) i used it then at the suggestion of a tuner... so rather than rip me either enlighten or FO...
dementedchord - not meant as a personal attack, rather just a heads up that people are very sensitive about their instruments, and before you start fiddling with someone else's piano, be darn sure to let them know what you're doing and of course, have their permission. My studio grand cost me $65,000 and no one, but no one, except for my personal technician, touches it. For many owners, it can be an ultra-sensitive issue.
Last edited by John Brook; 1st November 2007 at 07:25 PM..