Gearslutz

Gearslutz (https://www.gearslutz.com/board/)
-   Music Computers (https://www.gearslutz.com/board/music-computers/)
-   -   Melodyne vs Revoice (https://www.gearslutz.com/board/music-computers/1315562-melodyne-vs-revoice.html)

Skrinsen 19th June 2020 01:30 PM

Melodyne vs Revoice
 
Hi!

I´ve been using Celemony Melodyne for years, but are getting mails from Synchroarts about Revoice Pro deals. Now it´s time to either upgrade to Melodyne 5 or Revice Pro 4.

Anyone here with experience with both? Pro and cons? Are there any good arguments for having both?

Skrinsen

Geronimos Guitar 19th June 2020 01:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skrinsen (Post 14809157)
Hi!

I´ve been using Celemony Melodyne for years, but are getting mails from Synchroarts about Revoice Pro deals. Now it´s time to either upgrade to Melodyne 5 or Revice Pro 4.

Anyone here with experience with both? Pro and cons? Are there any good arguments for having both?

Skrinsen

Tough question, I use Revoice Pro 4 since a couple of years and love it, for vocal aligning (in bulks), de-essing and for vocal tuning. I preferred the Revoice tuning algorithm a lot to Melodyne Studio 4 (which I also have since a couple of years). I definitely used Melodyne for polyphonic stuff, because Revoice can't do that, and for tuning kicks etc., but never for vocal tuning. Revoice just felt and sounded better in my opinion. But now I have tested Melodyne 5 and I have to say that I love it. The new tuning macro is absolutely great, sounds fantastic. Also love the other new features (low frequency kick detection, leveling etc.). Means: I will upgrade to 5 definitely. But I wouldn't want to miss Revoice either. Each of them has their strength (Revoice: really fast aligning of bgvs and doubles), both sound very good. You will need both in the end :-)

matskull 20th June 2020 03:00 AM

Revoice sounds better than melodyne 4 (haven't tried 5) for timing and tuning, to my ears at least.

On both my machine though it's always been a pretty non responsive, slow, fragile software
Using it feels painful to me unfortunately, even the mouse feels sluggish using it, support just seems to have ignored my request for help, that's unfortunate...

richie0801 30th July 2020 12:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Skrinsen (Post 14809157)
Hi!

I´ve been using Celemony Melodyne for years, but are getting mails from Synchroarts about Revoice Pro deals. Now it´s time to either upgrade to Melodyne 5 or Revice Pro 4.

Anyone here with experience with both? Pro and cons? Are there any good arguments for having both?

Skrinsen

What did you go with?