So the Buchla arrived midday yesterday. Sorry there's no unboxing video... it's not of my generation and perhaps a little too commodity fetishistic.
Receiving the Easel
Anyways, true to their word, Buchla included an iProgram card. Score. Everything else I ordered was pretty much there (extra cabling). It was packed professionally--everything good here. Plus: ROGAN KNOBS! I was really hoping those would become standard on the new Easels. Lo and behold, this Easel has the more attractive knobs. Bonus.
However, there were two minor 'issues' with it. Shortly after powering up the Easel it became apparent the pressure was not being output from a few of the keys (18, 24, 27). They would trigger--but not in rapid succession. I opened the Easel up, lo and behold, the power bus cable was loose--probably from shipping. Once tightened up the touchplate worked fine. Whew! Note to Buchla: use more robust power distribution cables in the future.
The second issue was the Pulser Mode switch. It did not want to lock in the 'up' position (triggered mode). After a little fiddling it partially snapped into place. Then it operated as normal. Seems it partially slipped? A little tightening on the screw mount and it seemed fine.
Playing the Easel
In the many, many months since ordering the Buchla I've had time to read the manual. Watch all the instructional and performance videos. Study up on the principles of 'west coast' synthesis, and so forth. I was pretty well prepared for the experience and it went well... but the possibilities and nuances of this instrument are staggering.
Sound programming-wise, sometimes things don't go as planned. Yes, conjuring up the Buchla bongo sound is pretty simple--the Easel likes to go in that direction. It does the 'sequenced/pulsed' background with a lead line thing very well. It certainly manages to create the 'what we thought in the 1960's that computers sounded like inside' or 'this is a brawl between the id, ego and superego of a Martian sentient device' and the like. There is a
lot of interesting garbage to be found--sounds that, while cool, are probably not musically useful. A lot of good sounds too. You need to have your wits about you. Plus, yesterday was day one. I didn't expect to master the synth in a single day.
Overall
I did crack it open this morning. Reverb tank was secured. No roly poly screws, no weird rattles. No obvious defects. It appears that most or all of the criticisms raised earlier this year were addressed in one fashion or another. Sonically--it sounds like a Buchla... precisely what I expected. To be honest, it sounds a little better than I expected. Very full, clean and clear response. Capable of massive low end. Great!
But.... there are a few suggestions I'd offer:
(1) the 218e touchplate could use additional support on the corners facing the musician. I want my playing surface to be solidly moored and unmoving. There is a bit of a wiggle when you 'dig in' to play. Since receiving my Easel yesterday I double checked some of the better Buchla videos and, sure enough, you can see those move the slightest bit. (2) The access port on the side is totally open. While you wouldn't want to drag your Easel across town in the rain, but it would be great if there was something to close or protect the ports. The Easel is, after all, supposed to be in a case. Small complaint that doesn't affect me much.(3) Setting up wi-fi for the iProgram Card is a little annoying. Why does it have to springboard off your local wi-fi? Why can't it just have its own little network? However, it works like a charm and does precisely what it is supposed to. It is weird to have a semi-modular/modular synth like the Easel have presets. Due to the sheer bozosity of the options presented, this is a good thing.
Conclusion
Overall pretty happy, but I'm going to forward my concerns about the two issues to Buchla so they are aware of them. I believe the touchplate issue occurred during shipping--more secure buss ports would solve this issue. In the grand scheme of things, this was worrying and frustrating for a bit until I tightened things down. Still, for the kind of money they are asking for the Buchla (4499!) nowadays things ought to be done right the first time. End users don't like having to pry their new toys open. Or, at least not this end user.
The switch issue? I dunno. Part of me thinks it needed a little bit of 'play' in it. The Pulser switch is odd--the top position locks, but the middle position can toggle downwards (spring loaded) to pulse once. So it is a spring loaded toggle switch. I believe it being new, combined with perhaps the slightest slipping on its mount, probably caused the issue. It fixed itself pretty quickly and I tightened it down a tad. Works great now. Still--was frustrating for a moment.
Bottom line: reasonably happy. Was annoyed it took *that* long to receive. Furthermore, I had to essentially threaten potential legal action (although THAT seemed to have worked well--they pulled an Easel out of someone's arse pretty quick). I am not convinced the iProgram card is worth 900 dollars. Ridiculous sum of money. It works, but there is a certain point when there is no way you are paying for 'use value' or 'production cost' or even 'labor cost.' I would recommend getting it as part of the new Easel/iProgram deal they are offering.
I felt the Easel was about 1000 dollars overpriced when it was 3999, which was the purchase cost for the Easel itself (not including 120 USD they charge for shipping... UPS no less... major price gouge even factoring in insurance cost). Now that they have raised the prices to 4499 I don't know. I am not sure I would have purchased the Easel if it cost that much money. At that point it would be (at least) 1500 dollars overpriced. Sometimes I'll play ball and pay extra for 'sign value' of an object if it is something I really, really want and a surcharge happy manufacturer happens to make it. But there are a lot of other times I would consider getting a substitute. When considering the total investment, including shipping and the obligatory extra cabling, a Music Easel is probably going to cost in the vicinity of 4700-4800 dollars.
At that point you are veering towards Modal Electronics cost..... Or a good start to a pretty well-specified modular synth. Not sure if the little Easel is worth that. Glad I didn't pay it. To be honest, their inability to deliver a product in time snagged me a free iProgram card, the cost of which mitigates the Easel to a 'reasonable' cost all things considered. I feel lucky. However, most of you wouldn't be that lucky.
I would think long and hard on this decision, because it was a pain in the ass. Buying something like this should be a pleasant experience (aside from spending the money or catching hell from one's significant other). After the point of sale it should breeze along to a state of absolute consumerist joy. This experience, although having turned out for the better, was fairly bittersweet. Given the current state of the company, which I imagine veers from one mini-crisis to another to manage on top of the lawsuit, it also seems risky. Honestly, I believe Buchla is probably a 'bozo' company. Or at least ran by bozos. Their entire operation just reeks of shortsightedness, puffery and awful business management.