Flex pitch, how does it stack up?
Old 19th July 2013
  #1
Gear maniac
 

Thread Starter
Flex pitch, how does it stack up?

Vs. Melodyne specifically. We all know it is monophonic. That's fine with me. Workflow wise it looks great. Mostly I want to know how it sounds.
Old 19th July 2013
  #2
Lives for gear
Tried it today and found it easy to use, but had little success--I was trying to tune an upright bass but there was too much bleed from other instruments in the track
Old 19th July 2013
  #3
Lives for gear
 
Lee Wilson's Avatar
 

I use Melodyne and to be honest (and from what little time I've had with FlexTime) I'd say I prefer FlexTime, the display, the handles, the tuning bars (or whatever they are called) it all works so well.
Old 19th July 2013
  #4
Gear Head
 
johnnyws's Avatar
 

Anybody else use Flex Pitch yet? Pros and cons?
How does it sound compared to Melodyne?
Old 19th July 2013
  #5
Gear maniac
 
Silky Smoove's Avatar
 

Being a dedicated Melodyne guy, I was skeptical of Apple's built in solution. I haven't really dug into it, but I've read reports that the algorithm doesn't sound as good as Melodyne. That's third hand Internet speak, so I wouldn't trust that opinion until I hear it for myself.

Additionally, I have the cheapo version of Melodyne which doesn't include the audio to midi function. I was pleasantly surprised to find it in the Apple plugin.
Old 19th July 2013
  #6
Gear Head
 
johnnyws's Avatar
 

Smile

Quote:
Originally Posted by Silky Smoove View Post
Being a dedicated Melodyne guy, I was skeptical of Apple's built in solution. I haven't really dug into it, but I've read reports that the algorithm doesn't sound as good as Melodyne. That's third hand Internet speak, so I wouldn't trust that opinion until I hear it for myself.

Additionally, I have the cheapo version of Melodyne which doesn't include the audio to midi function. I was pleasantly surprised to find it in the Apple plugin.
Thanks for the info.
If you try it for yourself please post something here. That would be helpful.

Anybody else try it yet?
Old 19th July 2013
  #7
Lives for gear
 
TreyM's Avatar
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by PB+J View Post
Tried it today and found it easy to use, but had little success--I was trying to tune an upright bass but there was too much bleed from other instruments in the track
Did you attempt to use an expander to isolate the bass better first? Give that a shot.
Old 19th July 2013
  #8
Gear nut
 

The main problem i'm having is that there is not the note separation that Melodyne has.

Melodyne separates every note so it can be worked with and it is adjustable whereas so far it seems like Logic doesn't see every note hence it is hard to adjust every nuance you may wish to. You can use the scissors tool and separate the notes further but it is definitely not the same elegance as Melodyne.
This may come in time i don't know?
Having used Melodyne for a long long time it may just be that I'm use to that and I do find personally that the first software I use tends to be my favorite!

The sound seems relatively very good without too many artifacts probably consistent with Melodyne IMHO.
Old 19th July 2013
  #9
Gear Head
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by chugbry View Post
so far it seems like Logic doesn't see every note hence it is hard to adjust every nuance you may wish to.

The algorithm is suppose to be smart in that it will ignore un-pitched consonants, as you don't need to correct these. Suppose to sound better if you don't correct these.

Melodyne recognizes everything graphically, but who knows, the algorithm may ignore shifting these unpitched consonants beneath the covers... I'm not sure.
Old 19th July 2013
  #10
Gear nut
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by jcoyle View Post
The algorithm is suppose to be smart in that it will ignore un-pitched consonants, as you don't need to correct these. Suppose to sound better if you don't correct these.

Melodyne recognizes everything graphically, but who knows, the algorithm may ignore shifting these unpitched consonants beneath the covers... I'm not sure.
Yeah i see that but it would in my Op be more useful if you could change monophonic riffs etc to something different if you wanted to. I guess that would mean being able to select at any transient you wish to adjust. I'm not saying what is there isn't good at all it just could be a bit more elegant? maybe
Old 19th July 2013
  #11
Gear maniac
 

^
True about note separation. Sometimes two words gets one region. But you also got pitch drift on both sides of the region so you get a bit of control over these words.
But kind of the same problem did(and do still) the transient detector have when Logics 9 drumreplacement came out.
Old 19th July 2013
  #12
Gear Head
 

If two notes get detected as one, you can split the detected note with the pencil tool. Melodyne has the same problem, and there you split with the Note Separation Tool.

Also, if a note isn't detected, you can force it to detect the note, but I'm not sure how to do that yet... but I saw it done.
Quote
1
Old 20th July 2013
  #13
Lives for gear
 
Lee Wilson's Avatar
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by jcoyle View Post
If two notes get detected as one, you can split the detected note with the pencil tool. Melodyne has the same problem, and there you split with the Note Separation Tool.

Also, if a note isn't detected, you can force it to detect the note, but I'm not sure how to do that yet... but I saw it done.


you can split the detected note with the pencil tool.

Great find, really useful.
Old 20th July 2013
  #14
Lives for gear
It´s really great to have this in Logic now..I can see melodyne be used less now for me. Have not scrutinised the quality fully yet, but it seems fine to me so far..
Old 23rd July 2013
  #15
Gear addict
 
Cheech's Avatar
 

Ive used auto tune, for the past few years, so I gave the flex pitch a shot on a pretty rough vocal yesterday, and I have to admit I was impressed.

I still need more time with it, but in my experience I noticed that the vocal sounded pretty natural after tuning.

Anyone else hear that?



I take all of the above statements back. After trying to tune a legit recorded vocal, with all the frustration Flex Pitch has caused.... It needs serious work.
Old 23rd July 2013
  #16
Lives for gear
 
pinkheadedbug's Avatar
 

I like it, it's good. Sound quality is certainly competitive with AT and Melodyne and the interface is better.
Quote
1
Old 23rd July 2013
  #17
Lives for gear
 
Rufuss Sewell's Avatar
 

Strangely... as a Melodyne missionary... I really like it so far.

I'm missing the note transition tool, but it seems the pitch drift tool can get close.

So far I'm feeling really good about it.
Old 24th July 2013
  #18
Lives for gear
 
grooveminister's Avatar
I didn´t manage to split a wrong detected not with the pencil tool.
Is there a special trick I need to do?
I tried clicking with the pencil tool on to the big fat block that represents the note that is indeed two different notes... I did that where I wanted to devide both.
Old 24th July 2013
  #19
Gear nut
 

The audio sounds fine to my ear. The integrated interface is much easier to use IMO. There might be some "power" use of Melodyne I don't need that others will take advantage of, but for general pitch correction I doubt I'll fire up Melodyne much anymore.

I haven't tried flextime for LPX yet. I thought that it was kind of cumbersome in LP9 and because of that didn't use it much. Maybe I'll go back and try that as well now that I'm hooked on flexpitch.
Old 24th July 2013
  #20
Lives for gear
 
pinkheadedbug's Avatar
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by grooveminister View Post
I didn´t manage to split a wrong detected not with the pencil tool.
Is there a special trick I need to do?
I tried clicking with the pencil tool on to the big fat block that represents the note that is indeed two different notes... I did that where I wanted to devide both.
You use the scissor tool to split notes.
Old 24th July 2013
  #21
Lives for gear
 
grooveminister's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by pinkheadedbug View Post
You use the scissor tool to split notes.
That´s what I tried next, scissor-tool didn´t work eighter in the flex-pitch graph.
Where do I have to click?
Left- or right-click? Magic Mouse here...
Old 24th July 2013
  #22
Gear addict
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by grooveminister View Post
That´s what I tried next, scissor-tool didn´t work eighter in the flex-pitch graph.
Where do I have to click?
Left- or right-click? Magic Mouse here...
It's kind of weird but you don't actually place the pencil directly on the waveform to get the note to re-analyze - for some reason you have to drag the line (which is a few bars to the right of the actual tool) over to the left so that IT marks a new note.
Old 24th July 2013
  #23
Gear interested
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nola111 View Post
It's kind of weird but you don't actually place the pencil/scissors directly on the note to split it - for some reason you have to drag the line (which is a few bars to the right of the actual tool) over to the left so that IT splits the note or marks a new note.
I noticed this too.

Personally I'm unimpressed with flexpitch. It seems fine if you use it in a simple manner but if you want to do the cool things the toolset seems to provide it sucks.

It also doesn't play with flex time and when you enable it it will remove any region fades you have.
Old 24th July 2013
  #24
Lives for gear
 
pinkheadedbug's Avatar
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Nola111 View Post
It's kind of weird but you don't actually place the pencil/scissors directly on the note to split it - for some reason you have to drag the line (which is a few bars to the right of the actual tool) over to the left so that IT splits the note or marks a new note.
I think you have something screwed up. I'm doing it right now by clicking with the scissors in the middle of the note.
Old 24th July 2013
  #25
Gear addict
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by pinkheadedbug View Post
I think you have something screwed up. I'm doing it right now by clicking with the scissors in the middle of the note.
Sorry, I was referring only to use of the pencil tool, not the scissors tool. I'll edit to clarify.
Old 24th July 2013
  #26
Gear nut
 

It's great. I won't be ditching Melodyne just yet, but for most tasks Flex Pitch will suffice, and won't suffer from the clunky data management Melodyne necessarily needs.

But... Why can't Flex Pitch and Flex Time work together? Leave Flex Pitch to sort out the timing and the pitch corrections disappear - surely this is a bug, not a feature??
Old 24th July 2013
  #27
Gear addict
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jack Orff View Post
But... Why can't Flex Pitch and Flex Time work together? Leave Flex Pitch to sort out the timing and the pitch corrections disappear - surely this is a bug, not a feature??
Not sure what you mean - Flex Pitch is basically Pitch AND Time all in one. Timing can be adjusted while in Flex Pitch mode.
Quote
1
Old 25th July 2013
  #28
Gear maniac
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jack Orff View Post
But... Why can't Flex Pitch and Flex Time work together? Leave Flex Pitch to sort out the timing and the pitch corrections disappear - surely this is a bug, not a feature??
Drag the note ends right or left to lengthen or shorten note lengths. It's not done the same way as Flex Time when in Flex Pitch mode, but it's there.
Quote
1
Old 25th July 2013
  #29
Lives for gear
 
Lee Wilson's Avatar
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by grooveminister View Post
That´s what I tried next, scissor-tool didn´t work eighter in the flex-pitch graph.
Where do I have to click?
Left- or right-click? Magic Mouse here...
Are you looking at the waveform at the bottom of the screen - ie the waveform editor - or are you looking at the waveform in the arrange page* ?

(*now called the Main Page)


Quote
1
Old 25th July 2013
  #30
TNM
Lives for gear
I feel vari audio has the edge with pitch and stretch quality on vocal, but flex pitch seems to work better on more sources, like mono instruments as well.

Overall, after now using it for the week, I believe it's as good as melodyne, honest.

I have melodyne editor and use it in s1 and compared it head to head, and I feel logic has even better integration than celemonys ARA, so I understand why apple did it their own way.

Plus, apple have a patent already for polyphonic and word is its coming.

I'd still keep melodyne around for when I use studio one though.
New Reply Submit Thread to Facebook Facebook  Submit Thread to Twitter Twitter  Submit Thread to LinkedIn LinkedIn  Submit Thread to Google+ Google+ 
 
Post Reply

Welcome to Gearslutz Pro Audio Forum!

Registration benefits include:
  • Ability to make and reply to posts
  • Access to members-only giveaways & competitions
  • Interact with VIP industry experts in our guest Q&As
  • Access to members-only sub forum discussions
  • Access to members-only Chat Room
  • Get instant lifetime access to the world's best private pro audio Classifieds for only USD $20
  • List your eBay auctions for free
  • Remove this message!
You need an account to post a reply. Create a username and password below and an account will be created and your post entered.

 
 
Slide to join now Processing…
Thread Tools
Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Forum Jump
 
Register FAQ Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Search