Shootout of 18+ VO Mics (Neumann, AKG, Blue, Shure, Miktek, Lauten, RODE, etc.)
I'm a longtime GS reader and first-time poster. I've operated a small, but active, voiceover studio for the past several years. During that time, I've benefitted tremendously from the insights and examples of other users here on GS as I've gradually expanded and refined my studio gear.
At various points, I've owned and used more than 20 VO mics, most in the mid-to-upper-mid price range ($500-$1500 retail price). Whenever I acquired a new mic, I'd make a test recording using a standard VO script that accentuates plosives and sibilance. That way, I could better compare the mic's performance against others I had used. In essence, I conducted a six-year shootout.
As a service to other VO artists and GS readers who might want a side-by-side comparison of a wide range of mics, I've compiled short clips from the test files I produced for 18 of the mics. The mics (listed in approximate order of ascending price) include:
Nearly all of the mics were in excellent-to-mint used condition when I purchased them, but it's possible there might be some divergence from how a new mic would sound.
The files linked below are in 24-bit WAV format, normalized to around -21.7 LUFS. With the exception of one microphone (explained later), these are the raw, unprocessed recordings. The recording space was consistent across all the files. I have a well-treated and mostly isolated booth that creates a pretty neutral sound environment, except for some HVAC rumble between 20-60 Hz and a mild room resonance peak between 90-130 Hz, both of which I tame in post-production. (I use Room EQ Wizard software to measure room resonance.)
My signal chain has changed over time, but the two chains are similar in that they are relatively clean and uncolored. They are:
mic > Focusrite ISA Two pre > Focusrite 2i2 interface (for the Oktava, Shure, AT and Miktek mics)
mic > John Hardy M-1 pre (w/Jensen upgrade) > UA Apollo Twin Duo interface (for the rest of the mics)
For three of the mics (the Lauten Atlantis, Kiwi and TLM 107), I've included multiple test files highlighting some of their voicing (Atlantis) and polar pattern (Kiwi and TLM 107) options that I've used in VO work.
As I noted above, one test file had limited processing added. My CAD E100S is from the bad production run about five years ago that was notoriously noisy (self-noise ~20-25 dB). The price was right and it otherwise sounded great, so I kept it. For the test file in the shootout, I applied Izotope RX's Spectral De-noiser plug-in to reduce the mic's self-noise to more closely approximate a non-defective unit.
A couple of notes about my vocal performance. First, my voice is somewhat inconsistent across the files because the tests were conducted at different times. In some cases, my voice was a little ragged (hoarse or phlegmy), affecting its tone and resonance, which shouldn't be attributed to the mic. Second, my distance away from the mics varied from 7-10 inches, based on what I determined to be the sweet spot for each mic on my baritone voice.
Finally, another mic I've owned and used is the RODE K2, but I couldn't find a test recording for it. It was a pleasant sounding mic, but it didn't quite suit my voice, even after I upgraded its tube. It was smooth in the mid frequencies, but brittle at the high end and lacked body in the low end. The closest comparator in my test files is the Miktek C7, but with slightly less body and more sibilant.
I have my own opinions about which of the mics sound best for my voice in VO applications (which is why most of the mics on the list have found new homes over the years). I'd be curious to know what other professionals on GS think of them and whether I might have made a mistake in jettisoning any of the mics. (There are a couple I wish I'd held onto, but I didn't really need such an expansive (and expensive) mic locker.)
I hope this is helpful to the GS community.
Last edited by VO Storyteller; 8th November 2020 at 02:12 PM..
Reason: Typo