Oh I know that.
Ill try and make it clear though. I play in a band context, not recording. I dont use my Virus in multi timbral mode - nor would I kyura or iridium.
I run an Fantom 7, with Peak, Virus Ti2 and a Deep Mind. Each has their own strengths. Virus is the mod matrix, envelope decay slopes, and the amount of core waveforms available with the spectrals. its week point is the filters which are functional but nothing more, and lack of slop (in DSi terms) or drift (well there is SOME there hard coded but its not as natural or as controllable as more modern VAs) - and of course the aliasing which isnt massive but is there. It does the 90s/2000s sounds really well (deep mind covers 80s, Peak more modern sounding - and Fantom covers most bases actually but has poor mod matrix).
Technical capabilities of Virus, Kyra an irridum are of course readily available - and its obvious where each has strengths and weaknesses. Provided Kyra/Iridium offers the unique sound design parts Virus does (and they both do - iridium more than Kyra but they do most things virus does in that regard).
HOWEVER what they SOUND like at core level is what Im most interested in at this point. The question is really, with a single sound, doing a basic detuned twin saw brassy type sounds (for instance), or a typical moog esc lead sound, or a DX7 bell type sound - which of the 3 sounds more authentically analogue (using any tricks up its sleeve). Which is fattest, most harmonically rich etc.
That is and foremost my choice making criteria. Of course wave table style sounds have their own thing - and are welcome, as is FM 9that Iridium does well), etc BUT there all textures and I know which Id like and which Im not bothered about - core sound however is very important.
so given all that... If you had to do a traditional synth brass, moog lead and DX7 bell sound. Used as single patches - nothing more, nothing less. Which of the 3 synths best dopes this?
yes Im aware there are other alternatives to look at - Proper analogues like Rev 2, P6 - Hydrasynth, nords etc, BUT they dont offer the functionality I m, looking for elsewhere. All 3 of these synths have what Im looking for on a technical capability front - its the sound, filter quality, feel etc I dont know about.