Quote:
Originally Posted by
bluegreengold
take another look at the schematics. the efx are on an analog bus and are routed through lousy amps twice.
I did look and no they're not. All the mixing is performed before the DAC. You can mute the effects and the signal path is exactly the same. If you're referring to using the individual outputs (which aren't present on the SY77 or SY99) rather than the main outputs, the individual outputs only pass through one less op amp stage; the signal path is otherwise pretty much identical.
Quote:
As for whether the verbs are worse than the spx90, they're really not much different, perhaps fewer parameters to tweak, but for general use the output is similar. Grainy early reflections and reverse verb is still grainy ER etc. If they don't sound muted and hissy, they are a lot more useful.
The SPX90 was a barely adequate reverb in 1985 (although it was actually relatively powerful for modulation effects thanks to the MOD chip, which provides 16 LFOs). There are only 32 memory reads or writes per sample, which doesn't really allow for enough delay lines, taps, etc. for good reverb. Almost all other effect processors are more powerful than this.
The SPX90 also had only 524 ms total delay memory. Minus the pre-delay there's about 408 ms remaining for reverb. That's again barely adequate, not really enough for anything good.
The TG77 and others use the same amount of memory (16kwords) but a higher sample rate (48-55.93 kHz, depending on the model). So the delay memory is reduced to between 293 and 341 ms, with about 291 ms available for reverb. Because of this smaller delay memory, the SPX90 algorithms couldn't be ported directly, so new ones were written. They're not only less flexible, they're also much more metallic and all around sound considerably worse.
So basically the SPX90 was marginal already, and with new algorithms and less memory available for reverb, it's pretty much awful. This would be adequate for a PSR keyboard or XG module, but pretty lame in a flagship workstation, especially when all the competitors actually had good effects. And throwing in 4 effect processors doesn't really make it any better.