just putting together a new room in Tenerife, Spain. I have always made my own bass traps in the past using 703, always worked great. Now I dont live in Canada anymore, I am living in Tenerife. I have a small little studio room, maybe 14 by 11 by 9ft. I went to the local music store to ask about acoustic products since I couldn't source any rigid fibreglass insulation on the Island.
Of course, Auralex was what was suggested. Never having used their stuff before, I thought , "well, it must work, they are really famous, " I ordered 8 Lernds and bought a bunch of their foam. I have put some of the foam up and am awaiting delivery of the LERNDS. Thought I'd hop on here...and sheesh...seems like nobody is diggin the foam.
I must say, the foam I have put up, (on first reflection points and a smathering on a wall for which to back vocalists in) sounds pretty ok to me. NOw I'm really worried after reading here for an hour that the LERNDS are just crap.
My only other local option is fluufy rolls of fibregalss that they sell here, Ive read a little about people compressing it, keeping it in plastic, using it as corner fill etc, Im not sure, its a bummer.
Shipping GIKs products from the UK is the next option, but Canary Islands is a zone 7 ...expensive. I know how much I used to pay for my homemade traps when I was in Canada with 703 and I'm finding it hard to justify paying 8 to 10 times more when all is said and done with shipping.
so, people, are the LERNDS really, really a waste of time?
Thanks for your answer. In this case they may actually cost less than homemade traps, crazy as it seems. So, maybe, your implying, LERNDS aren't totally crap? They might actually make the bass response in my room, even and useable (as their advertising suggests..)????
Re. the mineral wool.Its not actually the pink stuff, its the yellow stuff. It comes in a roll or a slab...but this isnt like an owens corning slab, you can pinch right into it with your thumb and forefinger and it doesnt really hold its shape. Has anyone had any luck working with this lightweight mineral wool, and if so , any tips?
I'm tearing my hair out and am going to lose sleep, seriously, this will wreck my head cause Im a gearslut.obsiesive thinker. agh!
The problem with LENRDs is that they are too small to have much effect below 200Hz or so.
I imagine you should be able to find rockwool in Spain, if you really want to DIY. If you don't want to DIY, then you'll have to pony up to get traps that are more effective where all the action is (under 100Hz).
Indeed, I think I will be going the DIY route with this lightweight rockwool, which Im assured is the only kind available on the islands. Anyone else have any experience using rolled, not very dense, rockwool. Tips on working with this stuff would be appreciated. Im considering just making big rolls out of it for the corners, and making a purely cosmetic frame to stretch material over, and hide thide the rolle dup rockwool behind it.
Yikes, yeah that look fairly impotent under 200 HZ.
Good news is I found some dense rigid mineral wool today!
Took me all day driving around industrial estates, poking around warehouses and pestering sleepy spaniard workers. I don't have the specific density, but in appearance, weight and squishingness it appears much the same as OC703. It comes with silver paper glued onto one side and is designed to de used as roofing in warehouses, to keep the heat in...T The guy told me they haven't sold any since they got it in four years ago, which is hardly suprising seeing as the temperature rarely drops below 20 degrees in Tenerife. Needless to say I got a good price
Already picked up some material and will hit the hardware store tommorow for wood and brackets. I'll post pics. Tonight, I hope to sleep
Like to say thanks to Ethan for having such a great site, I have consulted it in the past and spent much of the morning on it today getting some important facts straightened out in my head.
The problem with LNRDs isn't just that they don't work well for bass absorption (though they don't), it's also that they work about as well throughout the frequency spectrum if not better. In other words, you're absorbing about as much at 4Khz as you are at 125Hz. That's the very definition of a poorly designed bass trap.