they all sound quite similar to me. nice VO btw.
4 or 5 times listening thru (just a pair of bx8 monitors where i am) i keep coming back to 1, maybe just because there was the least smacking sounds, but i'm trying to be obvective. 2 sounded weaker, distant even, as if you've leaned back a tad away from the mic. i found 3 a hair boomy, the presence being the most powerful here. 4 sounds the most like 1 imo, but becomes almost unusable if only for the mouth sounds (take a sip of water!)
i think they all sound great and certainly usable once cleaned up in the box. tell us the signal path if you don't mind?
edit: best wishes to you and everyone affected by the storm!