![]() | All Advertisers |
| Member Services Directory | Classifieds | Reviews | Jobs | Deal Zone | Merchandise | Marketplace | Facebook App | Books, DVDs & Gadgets | Video Vault | Tips & Techniques |
| |||||||
New Reply | Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| | #1 |
| Gear nut Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 93
Thread Starter | Culture Vulture VS Culture Vulture Mastering Edition
I need some help here, I'm about to treat myself to something special, but have a serious question.... I've only experimented with the mastering edition (loved it to death) and was wondering whether I could save some money and get the normal Culture Vulture??? I'm really only wondering how much the sonics differ between these two units??? |
| | |
| | #2 |
| Lives for gear Joined: Aug 2004 Location: South of South
Posts: 820
|
The sound shouldn't differ much at all, it is only the balanced in and outs and the detented outputs pots on the mastering edition that diifere from the normal version. great box |
| | |
| | #3 |
| Gear nut Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 122
|
R. Meltzer had something to say about culture vulture in his book, "Gulcher." Probably not applicable here except as pertains to rockroll as social phenomonon. All knob fiddlin' referred to as euphamism only. Good read if you can find it.
__________________ the only thing that separates us the from the monkeys is the zookeeper. |
| | |
| | #4 |
| Gear nut Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 93
Thread Starter |
In various descriptions, I read some talk of "military grade tubes" in the "Mastering Edition", could the sound differ dramatically as a result???
|
| | |
| | #5 |
| Gear nut Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 93
Thread Starter |
BUMP
|
| | |
| | #6 |
| Lives for gear Joined: Jul 2008 Location: @$tr@L pL@n3
Posts: 1,511
| MV owner here...
The Mastering one has Valves that will last longer. Plus the knobs have steps, while the NO Mastering one just turns freely, so it's difficult to set previous settings again... to me it is just a matter of how do you use it: experimentally? Go normal version. You get that final touch from the Culture Black Thing? You know what can give you? Go Mastering Version (it can give you a lot). YOMV... your opinion may vary
__________________ |
| | |
| | #7 |
| Gear Guru |
regular non MV here and I love it. when I ordered mine from mercenary they were out of the regular version so they sent me the mastering version. I guess I had it for almost a month before they got me the regular version. guess they figured it'd be hard to give up - but it's a steep increase in price. anyway - bottom line is - sonically they sound/function the same in my rig. I've got mine on an effect bus that I use to run final mixes through before going back into the box. it really gives stuff a solid true analog feel. I also use it as a straight up distortion effect in weird and extreme ways. It's a flexible box and works in a wide range of applications. I couldn't justify the extra cost of the mastering version given the way that I use it - and knowing the history of how the non mastering version had been used up to that point. Great Box either way.
__________________ ... My band has a million unpaid downloads and all I got is this lousy T-shirt... |
| | |
| | #8 |
| Lives for gear Joined: Dec 2005 Location: H City
Posts: 1,062
| "The Phoenix is being updated continually and this unit is the Master version (suffix M) with higher stability and faster release than earlier models. A side chain filter has now been added to provide 75Hz & 150Hz, but more permutations are possible when the MC is used in stereo mode with the link switch engaged. The Master Phoenix is easier to recall as it has a mixture of indented and switched controls and the screwdriver adjustment on the chassis behind the meters controls the current through the valves on this unit, so this corrects to some extent for valve ageing. A screwdriver is supplied with the Master Phoenix and should be used periodically to adjust the meters to zero"
__________________ improvisation over bale:http://soundcloud.com/ajondo/christian-bale-bale-out-rmx FREE Kontakt Instrument: iMoog |
| | |
| | #9 |
| Gear maniac Joined: Dec 2005 Location: Amsterdam
Posts: 233
|
I have the mastering version and I used the non mastering version before. I think if I had to buy it again I might go for the non mastering version. We did a rough AB test once in the studio and we couldn't tell them apart. Before the test I had the feeling the non mastering version sounded warmer. the mastering version has different lowpass filters settings, why they choose for these specific filter frequencies I don't know. The non mastering knobs look much more classy, the mastering knobs look like the cheapest ones you can buy at a hobby electronics store. The stepped knobs are handy, but the bias knob is not stepped and very sensitive (but you can use the meter for setting that one). Oh and you - can - get lit meters when you ask for it, otherwise the only light will be the green powerlight on the front (plus the valves inside). |
| | |
| | #10 | |
| Lives for gear Joined: Mar 2006 Location: Bahstahn, MA
Posts: 2,687
| Quote:
__________________ Sean Eldon Qualls Mercenary Audio / sean@mercenary.com "They don't think it be like it is...but it do" - Oscar Gamble | |
| | |
| | #11 |
| Lives for gear Joined: Dec 2005 Location: H City
Posts: 1,062
| |
| | |
| | #12 |
| Gear Guru |
well, ya'll rule! I've had nothing but the best experiences with you guys. I got an SPL SMC from you guys that was bonk and you turned around the replacement asap so I could make my session. Thanks again! |
| | |
| | #13 |
| Gear Head Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 53
| ---- August 5th, 2011 Update: Welcome visitor! I guess you're here because you're wondering about the differences between the CV and the Mastering version? Well, jump right down to Post #26 (click) for the *definitive* comparison in a bite-sized all-in-one post. It contains everything that's been said so far, as well as new discoveries. Enjoy! ---- Hi everyone, We've decided to get a Culture Vulture for our studio, since we love what it does. However, we've only tried the non-Mastering version. The Mastering version has the following extras: * Balanced ins/outs * Detented knobs for easy recall * Higher quality valves which means the unit will live longer * Better matched valves to ensure that the two channels sound the same, which helps when processing stereo material We don't really care about the balanced ins/outs (it's a distortion unit after all), but the rest sounds very nice... very nice indeed. Particularly being able to recall settings by noting the knob positions, and of course easier stereo matching by being able to reference precise knob positions. Here are some questions: * Does anyone know if the detents on the knob are fine enough to avoid that problem of "oh snap, 11 sounds too subtle; OH SNAP, 12 SOUNDS TOO OVERWHELMING"? I hope it doesn't suffer the problem of overly broad knob steps? * How does it sound if you sweep the various parameters (particularly Bias and Drive) on the detented knobs? Does it sound harshly stepped? I would guess the benefit of easy recall given by the mastering version comes at the cost of being unable to do smooth sweeps for effect purposes? * I've heard that the detented knobs on the mastering version feel very cheap and flimsy, is this true? We are not in any hurry to get the unit and would really appreciate any and all answers to these questions, particularly the second question which could force us to get the regular version instead. Answers to these questions have not been seen elsewhere (I've checked all threads on GS re: the CV), and I'm sure it would definitely help out other prospective buyers as well. Thanks in advance. |
| | |
| | #14 |
| Gear Head Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 53
| ---- August 5th, 2011 Update: Welcome visitor! I guess you're here because you're wondering about the differences between the CV and the Mastering version? Well, jump right down to Post #26 (click) for the *definitive* comparison in a bite-sized all-in-one post. It contains everything that's been said so far, as well as new discoveries. Enjoy! ---- With a Culture Vulture Mastering Version in our studio, I'm now able to answer the questions for anyone that stumbles upon this topic: * The detents are only on the Input Drive and Output Volume knobs (not on the Bias knob), and they are extremely fine. There is no problem whatsoever of overly broad steps. You will be able to get exactly the result you want. Even sweeping the stepped drive knob doesn't sound harshly stepped at all. It is indeed very fine. * The detents on the knobs help greatly both for session recall purposes and when matching the volume of the two channels. Start out by setting the Input Drive of each channel to the same amount, then do the same for the Output Volume. Next, sweep the un-detented Bias knobs without any audio going through the unit (otherwise it affects the meters). Do this to match the VU meters for the two channels, as they show how much current flows through the valves and are very accurate. You will now have completely stereo-matched channels. This is unlike the non-Mastering Version, where people constantly complain of unmatched channels, due to its lack of detented knobs and its lower quality and less-matched tubes. I've heard plenty of people that see their non-Mastering units as "2 separate units" rather than a stereo processor for these reasons. If processing stereo material is important to you (and it most likely is), get the Mastering Version, no doubt about it. You can take a gamble with a regular version if you are trying to save some money, but you will risk getting tubes that sound very different for the two channels. * "Higher quality valves in the Mastering unit that live longer". I can't comment on this, but even if your non-Mastering version tubes fail, Thermionic (via Unity Audio UK) sells replacement tubes for £95. I can't really call the longer-life Mastering tubes a significant benefit, considering that replacement tubes are so affordable. * Lastly, about the various people reporting that the detented knobs feel cheap and flimsy: That's partly true. As mentioned above, the two controls that use detented knobs are the Input Drive and the Output Volume. The Input Drive feels VERY solid, smooth and high quality. The Output Volume is another story; it's plasticky, creaky and flimsy, but not more than to be a minor annoyance and it's still immensely usable. I have received word from from Unity Audio and Thermionic that they are looking for a matching replacement, and that if they find one it'll be easy to get a replacement kit and solder in the new pots yourself (or a friend that's good with electronics), or to send it in for a fee. That should answer all of the questions. In short: Get the Mastering Version, it is well worth it. Chris White |
| | |
| | #15 | |
| Gear maniac Joined: Sep 2009 Location: Melbourne Australia
Posts: 163
| Quote:
excellent post mate exactly what i needed to read..... | |
| | |
| | #16 |
| Gear addict |
@Chris White - Totally agree with your opinion of the non mastered version - mine has a creaky output knob on one channel & both channels sound different - not massively - but enough to make lining it up for stereo a bit of a pain in the arse.. The sound quality of what comes out of it though more than exonerates it!
|
| | |
| | #17 |
| Allons-y Joined: Dec 2008 Location: Belgium
Posts: 2,526
|
well I haven't heard the MV+ yet only the normal version but just looking at the site the MV+ has a distortion setting or two extra?
|
| | |
| | #18 |
| Gear Head Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 53
| ---- August 5th, 2011 Update: Welcome visitor! I guess you're here because you're wondering about the differences between the CV and the Mastering version? Well, jump right down to Post #26 (click) for the *definitive* comparison in a bite-sized all-in-one post. It contains everything that's been said so far, as well as new discoveries. Enjoy! ---- Hey everyone, glad to hear that you found my posts helpful. @Batchainpuller78: Both the normal and Mastering version have the exact same three distortion modes; Triode, Pentode 1 and Pentode 2. The differences between the two versions are listed earlier in this thread, see my posts (post #13 and #14). The one you're thinking of was the very limited-availability Anniversary edition which added extended overdrive and some additional distortion modes (10 rather than 3), but the extra modes were nothing other than a lowpass filter put in serial with the 3 original distortion modes, to soften them in various ways. Don't even think about trying to find an Anniversary edition though; they're long since sold out at every dealer in the entire world, and the chances of seeing one on eBay are very slim since very few were made and most people don't part with theirs. Sure, the filtering was a very nice extra to have built right into the box, but anyone can run their normal Culture Vulture through a filter and get better results, so you're really not missing out on anything worthwhile. Chris White |
| | |
| | #19 |
| Gear addict Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 328
|
Do you know where I can find a CV MV ? They were a limited addition and sold out some time ago AFAIK .
|
| | |
| | #20 | |
| Gear Head Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 53
| ---- August 5th, 2011 Update: Welcome visitor! I guess you're here because you're wondering about the differences between the CV and the Mastering version? Well, jump right down to Post #26 (click) for the *definitive* comparison in a bite-sized all-in-one post. It contains everything that's been said so far, as well as new discoveries. Enjoy! ---- Quote:
Are you in Europe? If so, I suggest using Thomann for the lowest prices: Normal: THERMIONIC CULTURE CULTURE VULTURE - Thomann UK Cyberstore Mastering Plus: THERMIONIC CULTURE CULTURE VULTURE MASTER PLUS - Thomann UK Cyberstore Refer to post #13 and #14 for the differences. The most significant difference is that the Mastering version is far better matched for stereo, which is a major reason to spend the extra cash on it. With the regular version you will most likely end up with two channels that sound quite different, making it difficult or time consuming to process stereo material with it (worst possible case you'd have to process the left/right channels 1 channel at a time, through just one of the distortion channels of the CV, to have the result sound the same). It's entirely down to luck whether you get a well-matched unit or not if you go for the normal version. With the Mastering version, Thermionic has gone through the trouble of finding extremely well-matched tubes so that you'll have zero issues processing stereo material. That was worth it for me. Chris White | |
| | |
| | #21 |
| Gear Head |
thx for the info. i have a culture vulture at home at the moment. but the left channel is broken. i got it a bit cheaper but can give it back or let it repair. but if the 2 channels are not well matched it´s no use for me cause i want to use it on my mixes. so i ask better to give it back and save some bucks for the mastering version...or does this problem of not well matched channels occur only rarely? what´s the experience of a normal culture vulture user? |
| | |
| | #22 |
| Gear interested Joined: May 2011
Posts: 8
|
i have the red mastering "Mullard" version, i think it's the bestculture vulture! I don't care about the stepped pots but i think the additionnal pentode and squash mods are killers. I use it mostly for mixing rock and it's kind of a magic box for me |
| | |
| | #23 |
| Gear addict Joined: Oct 2004 Location: Waterkant
Posts: 335
|
BTW, German musicstore now offers a limited run of units with green faceplate, mullard and siemens tubes, 10 distortion settings and an extra overdrive setting.
|
| | |
| | #24 | |
| Gear Head Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 53
| ---- August 5th, 2011 Update: Welcome visitor! I guess you're here because you're wondering about the differences between the CV and the Mastering version? Well, jump right down to Post #26 (click) for the *definitive* comparison in a bite-sized all-in-one post. It contains everything that's been said so far, as well as new discoveries. Enjoy! ---- Quote:
Any European that missed out on the Red faceplate Anniversary Edition can get the Musicstore.com-exclusive "Green Grand Opening Edition" which was made to celebrate the opening of that store. It seems to be the same as the Anniversary edition except that it has a Green faceplate instead. It definitely features the same Anniversary Edition Mullard tubes and the extra processing modes that apply various filters after the distortion circuitry. Note that it's based on the normal version, not the Mastering version (whereas the Anniversary edition came in both normal and Mastering). This means no detented input/output knobs or balanced in/out, but you WILL be getting extremely well-matched tubes since this is like a "normal version on steroids". The lack of detented knobs does however make it harder to match volumes between channels, and to recall settings later. Here are all 3 versions from that store, so that readers can compare: 1999 EUR Grand Opening Edition: Thermionic Culture - Culture Vulture Grand Opening Ltd. Ed.,Siemens/Mullard Tubes : Dynamics / sound adjustments 1489 EUR Normal Version: Thermionic Culture - Culture Vulture Stereo Valve Distortion : Dynamics / sound adjustments 1899 EUR Mastering Edition: Thermionic Culture - Culture Vulture Master Plus Stereo Valve Distortion : Dynamics / sound adjustments They're extremely limited so if anyone reading this has any urge for those extra filter modes - this is your only chance. You can just forget finding one via auctions later unless you search every day for years, so act immediately if you think you think this is for you. As an existing Mastering Edition owner, there's zero reason to change. The detented knobs are an important tool for recall, and the extra filter modes don't matter, as you can easily apply your own filter after the output of the Culture Vulture. However, I am sure having built-in filter modes is a pretty nice bonus for some people. With all this being said, I'd still suggest getting the Mastering PLUS instead. Read post #26 for information on that. Chris White | |
| | |
| | #25 | |
| Gear Head Joined: Aug 2005 Location: Seattle, WA
Posts: 64
| Quote:
Check the pic on their site it shows the P3 update: THERMIONIC CULTURE ALL VALVE DESIGN PROFESSIONAL AUDIO EQUIPMENT | |
| | |
| | #26 |
| Gear Head Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 53
| ------- UPDATED COMPARISON BETWEEN THE VARIOUS EDITIONS. THIS POST IS NOW THE ONLY COMPARISON YOU'LL EVER NEED. ------- My original comparison came from discussions with Thermionic Culture, but it turns out they had left out several of the differences. Then there's the whole "Mastering PLUS" thing, which is a massively updated Mastering unit that was released about a year ago (as it turns out, that's the one we have in our studio). The lack of a proper "press releases" area of Thermionic's site made this news hard to catch, as well as the fact that they've removed the product page for the old Mastering version. I've now been able to piece together what has happened, and the following covers *all* the differences between the three editions (Normal, the old Mastering Edition and the new Mastering PLUS), as well as everything else that's been said in the thread. This post is now the only comparison you'll ever need, and yes it has a lot of information, because it covers *everything* there is to know. 2007 or maybe even earlier: Culture Vulture Mastering Edition is released, with these differences compared to the Normal version:
Late 2010, maybe a bit earlier: Culture Vulture Mastering PLUS is released, and the old Mastering Edition is discontinued. Cosmetically it's a little bit different thanks to the new features, and the logo features the addition of the word "PLUS". There's a remarkable array of improvements, not least of which is that it now uses the exact same ultra-high-quality tubes that were previously only used in the extremely limited Anniversary edition! The new Mastering PLUS brings the following changes:
Now here are some final words about the Mastering Plus: The distortion of this unit goes from 0.2% THD to 99.5% THD. It spans the whole range from "gentle warming" to "absolute and total destruction". You can use it to distort or warm individual tracks or busses, or even to process the entire 2-mix if the song calls for it. The new Military-grade valves with their massively improved frequency response mean that you've got an excellent and extremely flexible unit for every possible usage case, as it lets you go from transparent to gentle warming to in-your-face and everything in-between. Since these additional differences have been brought to light, I'll now say this without a shadow of a doubt: Get the Mastering PLUS edition. Don't even bother with the normal one. With the "Mastering PLUS" you're getting an incredible unit, with the insanely good tubes that used to be reserved for the Anniversary Edition. In fact, the only difference to the rare Anniversary Edition is the lack of some gimmicky, dedicated filter-distortion-modes. However, as mentioned previously, that's a minor point as you're far better off just routing the CV output through a filter of your own and getting exactly the effect you want. The "Mastering PLUS" is now the best Culture Vulture you can get, by a long stretch! Chris White |
| | |
| | #27 |
| Gear Head |
thanks for the info. i ordered me a normal version but had to send it back cause one channel was broken (repair said a resistor needed to be exchanged). now they send me the repaired unit. i wonder if its normal that you get a crack noise when switching between the modes. |
| | |
| | #28 | |
| Gear Head Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 53
| Quote:
Congratulations on getting a Culture Vulture! I'm sure you'll completely fall in love with it! Yes, the noise as you switch between modes is the way it should be, as the mode switch literally reconfigures the physical pins on the vacuum tubes, changing which current goes where. Vacuum Tubes are normally intended to be nothing more than clean amplifiers (they have a few more usage cases than that but that's the main one) and they usually have between 4-7 pins for the various inputs, gain, control voltages and outputs. The Culture Vulture achieves its beautiful distortion through applying extra gain along with various unintended pin configurations. As you're changing that mode switch, you're physically redirecting the electricity to the different pins, which leads to the different characteristics - and a brief noise as the pins readjust. Have fun! Chris White | |
| | |
| | #29 | |
| Gear Head Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 53
|
I just found out that there's a baby-Vulture coming out. A single channel version aimed at guitarists (since they only need 1 channel) but equally usable by someone that processes a lot of mono synths, like a Moog for instance. The valves are not as high quality as the top-quality military valves in the Mastering PLUS, but then again you're not getting this baby-Vulture for 2-bus processing, since it only has one channel and an inferior frequency response! I think it looks like a great idea for guitarists and other single-channel users, and it has a new "Presence" control not found on other units (my guess is that it's most likely a mid-range boosting EQ knob that's tuned to the mid-range frequency of an electric guitar, but that remains to be seen; if it is, then existing units can easily replicate it by boosting the material with an EQ before entering the vulture). Will be interesting to see what price it lands at and how it looks. Quote:
| |
| | |
| | #30 |
| Gear maniac Joined: Mar 2004 Location: England
Posts: 242
| ![]() here's the official pic |
| | |
New Reply
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| The Culture Vulture rocks!!!!! | Tetness | So much gear, so little time! | 14 | 3rd April 2008 04:12 AM |
| WHY unbalanced Vulture Culture? | Dirty Halo | High end | 27 | 8th July 2006 05:13 AM |
| |