Login / Register
 
Sampling rare groove from CD versus sampling from vinyl
New Reply
Subscribe
jedilaw
Thread Starter
#1
26th September 2008
Old 26th September 2008
  #1
Gear maniac
 
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 273

Thread Starter
jedilaw is offline
Sampling rare groove from CD versus sampling from vinyl

Yeah, this one might stir a debate or two:

I'm starting to get into the rare groove thing, looking for those unusual soul/funk tracks that are a little off the beaten path. Thing is, I don't have a turntable, just CD. I'm sure I can get clean results just copying over the uncompressed WAV files from a CD, but should I be looking to snag a USB turntable instead so I can sample from vinyl? Does it make that big of a sound difference when it comes to the samples you extract?

My thing is, it's not like I have the cheese for an SL-1200 MK2 or something of similar quality, and I can't imagine an inexpensive turntable really giving better results than a WAV file lifted directly off of a CD.

Thoughts?
#2
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #2
Gear maniac
 
termtables's Avatar
 
Joined: Sep 2007
Location: Vancouver, WA
Posts: 211

Send a message via AIM to termtables
termtables is offline
sometimes i like cd's because i dont have to clean up the grime. i'm over the whole crackle in my samples phase.
Quote
1
#3
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #3
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 5,217

beat you down is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by termtables View Post
sometimes i like cd's because i dont have to clean up the grime. i'm over the whole crackle in my samples phase.
seems to go in circles
like... i'm now back at noisy crackley samples.
#4
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #4
Lives for gear
 
tonymission's Avatar
 
Joined: Feb 2008
Location: ATL / Zone 3 / West End
Posts: 1,173

Send a message via AIM to tonymission
tonymission is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by termtables View Post
sometimes i like cd's because i dont have to clean up the grime. i'm over the whole crackle in my samples phase.
same.

oh -- and i sample everything.

read into that how you will.
jedilaw
Thread Starter
#5
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #5
Gear maniac
 
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 273

Thread Starter
jedilaw is offline
Is there any advantage in sampling vinyl at higher sample rates/bit rates than CD, e.g. 96k/24-bit or 88k/24-bit instead of 48k/16-bit? Does this give you more to work with in the original sample before you mix your track back down to CD quality?

Also, are the current crop of USB turntables generally good enough to extract quality samples, or does one need to spend the $400 on a Technics deck to get anything worth using?
#6
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #6
Lives for gear
 
Stitch333's Avatar
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Location: Western MA, USA
Posts: 3,503

Stitch333 is offline
There is something going on sonically to the sound of a 200gram vinyl captured on a thorens table through a tube phono pre that a CD will NEVER be able to get to...its rare I get to do it this way tho...
__________________
Little Studio

"Run to the hills, run for your lives."
-Iron Maiden
Quote
1
#7
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #7
Lives for gear
 
tonymission's Avatar
 
Joined: Feb 2008
Location: ATL / Zone 3 / West End
Posts: 1,173

Send a message via AIM to tonymission
tonymission is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by jedilaw View Post
Is there any advantage in sampling vinyl at higher sample rates/bit rates than CD, e.g. 96k/24-bit or 88k/24-bit instead of 48k/16-bit? Does this give you more to work with in the original sample before you mix your track back down to CD quality?

Also, are the current crop of USB turntables generally good enough to extract quality samples, or does one need to spend the $400 on a Technics deck to get anything worth using?
With a 12, you're spending all that money because the motor drives at such a constant speed allowing a DJ to properly cue the record and immediately -- and at high-ish resolution -- adjust the tempo of it on the fly (not to mention turntablism, etc). the cheaper turntables are fine for sampling, just make sure you purchase the proper cartridges.

Having a Technic is not gonna make anyone a better sampler unless you're trying to record some cuts or whatnot. As far as recording, the motor has nothing to do with the sound quality.

As far as the whole USB interface thing goes, I have no idea... never used one.
__________________
The Royalty - "Kings of the Keys"
@tonymission
#8
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #8
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 2,318

Brian! is offline
Sampling from CD is a lot easier but depending on the track/genre, you may get more desirable results from vinyl. I would definitely recommend against a USB turntable. I realize that you're trying to do it on the cheap but if you consider a sample like any other element of a track, it's worth investing in a quality signal chain.
#9
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #9
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 2,318

Brian! is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by jedilaw View Post
Also, are the current crop of USB turntables generally good enough to extract quality samples, or does one need to spend the $400 on a Technics deck to get anything worth using?
I would actually recommend against the standard Technics decks and to invest in a decent belt driven turntable. 1200s are direct driven and there is a lot of additional noise introduced where there is not with belt driven turntables.
Quote
2
#10
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #10
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,228

Fredrik is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by Brian! View Post
I would actually recommend against the standard Technics decks and to invest in a decent belt driven turntable. 1200s are direct driven and there is a lot of additional noise introduced where there is not with belt driven turntables.
True with a bad direct drive, not technics though since there is no direct connection between the motor and the platter. The shaft from the motor drives the platter via a big magnet with a air pocket between. And I garantee that 99% of all hip hop ever made is done on a Technics.
(ok don´t quote me on that)

About the CD´s, apart from the sound there are a lot of obscure stuff that isn´t available on CD at all. And oddball stuff can sometimes be found in the dollar bins. Use CD´s while you save up to a TT, doesn´t need to be a Technics but it should be a decent one with a good cart.
#11
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #11
Gear nut
 
Joined: May 2008
Location: South, US
Posts: 117

Zionpro is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fredrik View Post
About the CD´s, apart from the sound there are a lot of obscure stuff that isn´t available on CD at all. And oddball stuff can sometimes be found in the dollar bins. Use CD´s while you save up to a TT, doesn´t need to be a Technics but it should be a decent one with a good cart.

I agree with this...I mean vinyl has a sound of its own, but more importantly the fact that there are many records still out there that have no CD equivalent...so for 'rare' finds, vinyl is the only way to go.

If you only plan to sample--no cutting, scratching, etc. then you don't need to spend a lot on a TT. For example, I bought a Gemini. Now I know most people say stay away from this brand, but this one is an older "top of the line" model. It has the same features of a Technics (except pitch is +/- 8 instead of 10). The build isn't of the same quality, but it is bad at all (just not a Technics tank). Got it for $37 on ebay (avg. price for this model on ebay is like $50-70) I bought good carts. and a decent phono amp and was set. In all, I spent about the same as a decent USB TT, but I know this is of better quality than those on the lower end.

There are some nice USB TT that cost from $300-400. For that you could get two used technics and a mixer on ebay. My point is be wise about your purchase. Do you need on board pitch controls, quick stop, on-board light, etc. There are many options for someone seeking a good TT for sampling...Btw, i heard from owners that most of the USB TT are fine for sampling purposes...I personally just didn't trust the lower end ones...

IF you do the ebay thing...check the used TT. They are good deals to be had...for cheaper than a USB TT. The main thing is to remember you will need a phono pre if you don't already have one or mixer/receiver with phono input (for grounding purposes and RIAA Eq curve). Whereas, with USB TT you have everything you need to connect to PC and get it cracking...

lots of rambling...hopefully you get my points!
#12
27th September 2008
Old 27th September 2008
  #12
Lives for gear
 
Stitch333's Avatar
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Location: Western MA, USA
Posts: 3,503

Stitch333 is offline
I've never used the USB turntables but I don't think I ever will...

Let a turntable be what it is and an interface what it is.
Its when these pinheads in the marketing departments of audio companies start calling the shots that everything turns (and sounds) shit.
#13
30th September 2008
Old 30th September 2008
  #13
Gear addict
 
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 447

filin is offline
Another point to keep in mind is that CDs are often mastered (or remastered) with a lot more compression and limiting, which will give you a far fewer options in terms of mixing the sample.
#14
1st October 2008
Old 1st October 2008
  #14
Lives for gear
 
nukmusic's Avatar
 
Joined: Jun 2004
Location: Dallas, TX
Posts: 4,699

Send a message via AIM to nukmusic Send a message via Yahoo to nukmusic
nukmusic is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by filin View Post
Another point to keep in mind is that CDs are often mastered (or remastered) with a lot more compression and limiting, which will give you a far fewer options in terms of mixing the sample.
true info..

but that can work both ways depending on how you will use the sample.
__________________
.


Docta'J aka Big NUK
Practice Makes Progress
www.twitter.com/nukmusic
#15
1st October 2008
Old 1st October 2008
  #15
3 + infractions, forum membership suspended.
 
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 893

jbuehler is offline
You will be much more please with your drums if they are sampled from vinyl.

The other samples, maybe, maybe not.
jedilaw
Thread Starter
#16
1st October 2008
Old 1st October 2008
  #16
Gear maniac
 
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 273

Thread Starter
jedilaw is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by jbuehler View Post
You will be much more please with your drums if they are sampled from vinyl.

The other samples, maybe, maybe not.
Funny you should mention that. The question came to mind after I read an online listing for a box set of drum sounds on vinyl.

EDIT: this is it - Paul Nice's Complete Drum Library, a 6LP set over at Fat Beats. I was considering picking this up, but wasn't sure whether it was worth getting the extra gear I'd need to use it.
#17
2nd October 2008
Old 2nd October 2008
  #17
Lives for gear
 
cynic one's Avatar
 
Joined: Aug 2005
Location: san jose, califas
Posts: 2,608

cynic one is offline
cd, turntable, mp3, field recorder...it's all fair game.

great point about shit on vinyl not available on cd.

what bugs me are the cats who proclaim from the rooftops they only use vinyl. ok, you're artsier than me...who really gives a **** in the end? a sample is a sample is a sample.

and i been samplin from mp3s for certain things i can't get in any other form. lemme tell ya it works and you can't tell if you do it right!
#18
2nd October 2008
Old 2nd October 2008
  #18
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 793

DannyMac is online now
any deck with USB out is going to have shitty converters - there is no margin to put in good ones
#19
2nd October 2008
Old 2nd October 2008
  #19
Gear addict
 
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 447

filin is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by cynic View Post
and i been samplin from mp3s for certain things i can't get in any other form. lemme tell ya it works and you can't tell if you do it right!

Yeah man, lots of people far too scared of using mp3s for sampling. Obviously, a 64k stream is going to sound sucky for your main vocal (although...), but mp3s can work just fine.
jedilaw
Thread Starter
#20
2nd October 2008
Old 2nd October 2008
  #20
Gear maniac
 
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 273

Thread Starter
jedilaw is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by cynic View Post
cd, turntable, mp3, field recorder...it's all fair game.

great point about shit on vinyl not available on cd.

what bugs me are the cats who proclaim from the rooftops they only use vinyl. ok, you're artsier than me...who really gives a **** in the end? a sample is a sample is a sample.

and i been samplin from mp3s for certain things i can't get in any other form. lemme tell ya it works and you can't tell if you do it right!
Well, I think what matters in the end is how good your song sounds. Even low-quality samples can work in a good-sounding song, depending on how you process them. If you think about it, people rave about the 12-bit converters on the MPC-60, which obviously weren't even doing CD-quality sampling, much less 96k/24bit. Seems odd to fuss about using MP3s but praise the obsolete converters on the first-gen MPC...

Has anyone here used the Paul Nice drum library? Any good?
Quote
1
#21
2nd October 2008
Old 2nd October 2008
  #21
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 5,217

beat you down is offline
because of some "technical difficulties" i have been using mp3's for a minute, seemed ok but... now i got my stuff back and started sampling actual records again...
the difference seems huge, especially on drums and bass for some reason.

i think after a while you'll settle for less or adjust to ok mp3's like kids nowadays play crappy lo-res downloads on their i-pods.
once you hear the real thing again... you'll notice the difference.
Quote
1
#22
2nd October 2008
Old 2nd October 2008
  #22
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,228

Fredrik is offline
Yes, and at some time your finnished track containing mp3 will probably be converted again to mp3.
#23
2nd October 2008
Old 2nd October 2008
  #23
Lives for gear
 
cynic one's Avatar
 
Joined: Aug 2005
Location: san jose, califas
Posts: 2,608

cynic one is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fredrik View Post
Yes, and at some time your finnished track containing mp3 will probably be converted again to mp3.
thing is ......i guess i don't sample how a lot of people do anymore.

these days i'm trying to use shorter samples as the basis for my own instrument designs instead of just lifting a musical phrase. you take that approach and a whole new world opens up to you.

you can find a lot of shit in 320 VBR, which sounds decent enough to me. and i'm not even getting into FLAC
#24
21st October 2008
Old 21st October 2008
  #24
Gear addict
 
Bondtana's Avatar
 
Joined: Mar 2008
Location: NY
Posts: 312

Bondtana is offline
There are Cd's that you will never see the vinyl for, vinyl you will never see a CD for and mp3's that you will never see anywhere else. Fact, no matter who you are.
#25
20th March 2013
Old 20th March 2013
  #25
Gear interested
 
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 17

FineDineRecords is offline
I know a producer who made a track with an mp3 sample.

If the quality is good, and you are able to process it to sound great - nobody will ever really know...

The track is even featured on DJ sets, and they prob. think it was sampled from vinyl.

Nobody will ever know - besides why does everybody follow the old school when it is already 2013 and beyond?

Each to their own - but the technology is here for a reason.

---
#26
20th March 2013
Old 20th March 2013
  #26
Gear nut
 
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 105

Vibes Antagonist is offline
In my experience a lot of rare groove CDs have terrible quality... the highs can sound very harsh. I guess that's just bad conversion
#27
20th March 2013
Old 20th March 2013
  #27
Lives for gear
 
utters's Avatar
 
Joined: Mar 2008
Location: London, UK
Posts: 528

utters is offline
I thought I'd weigh in with some real world experience.

I produced a track once using vinyl samples from various sources; Drums from The Ventures, Miami and Detroit Emeralds, Loops from Uriah Heap, The Stylistics, various other bits and pieces...

The track was coming out on a major label and they wanted me to polish it up, so I set about finding every single sample on CD and re-creating the track. Didn't actually take too long, I just made up my REX files (I used to use Reason) to be the same length as the vinyl ones, then just replaced them in the session.

The track came out sounding lifeless, especially the drums. Once all the elements were combined, it didn't even sound any cleaner, re: crackle, noise, hiss etc? I was confused. Needless to say, the old version went ahead

Like somebody said, CDs are often reissued with a modern sounding re-master or in some cases a modern re-mix. They don't have the crunch you get from a vinyl, and often the midrange isn't as nice. Old CDs will also suffer from terrible A/D and just sound bad straight up

When you sample from a 70s record, you're getting an 100% analogue signal, from musicians fingers to pressing plant... It's a no brainer
Quote
2
#28
20th March 2013
Old 20th March 2013
  #28
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 5,217

beat you down is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by utters View Post
...I produced a track once using vinyl samples from various sources; Drums from The Ventures, Miami and Detroit Emeralds, Loops from Uriah Heap, The Stylistics, various other bits and pieces...

The track was coming out on a major label...
one track, many samples, big names, on a major label and it actually came out???

sounds sweet, but must've been a while ago.
#29
20th March 2013
Old 20th March 2013
  #29
Gear addict
 
lemonsquash's Avatar
 
Joined: May 2012
Location: Backwoods, Baby

lemonsquash is offline
I would gladly sample all sources but analog pitch is something digital devices can't emulate well to my ear. I need to sample my ish as pitched up as possible because 2,5 secs is the longest possible sampling time and i got four of those available. Love the digital pitch down of th SP tho
__________________
Fat rap beats.
#30
20th March 2013
Old 20th March 2013
  #30
Lives for gear
 
utters's Avatar
 
Joined: Mar 2008
Location: London, UK
Posts: 528

utters is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by beat you down View Post
one track, many samples, big names, on a major label and it actually came out???
Ha, yeah. Uncleared samples ftw
New Reply Submit Thread to Facebook Facebook  Submit Thread to Twitter Twitter  Submit Thread to LinkedIn LinkedIn  Submit Thread to Google+ Google+ 
 
Thread Tools
Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Similar Threads
Thread
Thread Starter / Forum
Replies
Illusive / Rap + Hip Hop engineering & production
3
CWsounds / Rap + Hip Hop engineering & production
10
eqverb / Rap + Hip Hop engineering & production
23
MACHINE / Rap + Hip Hop engineering & production
1
beatzz / Music Computers
5

Forum Jump

SEO by vBSEO ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.