29th June 2008
|
#1 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Mar 2007 Location: West "Ma' ****in" Oakland
Posts: 557
Thread Starter | Im Looking For A Quicker Way To Do This..HELP!
Im using Logic 8 as my Daw. I truly think external synth's sound a lil better. Right now my gear is midi up to it but its a longer process to lay the midi down, then track out the individual sounds as audio 1 by 1.
I was thinking, wouldnt it be faster to just play in the audio in the 1st place? Now im not the "best" player in the world by ANY means so what can i do to ensure timing so all the tracks i lay down will be in sync with the others? I know there is no such thing as audio quantizing so is there a workaround?
__________________
<<<--------"Hook" Mitchell was a Street Ball legend here in Oakland |
| |
29th June 2008
|
#2 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 5,221
|
there is no short cut i'm afraid.
i don't see what your midi problem is but if you don't like recording midi tracks first:
use a click track to lay down the first track for a bar or two.
loop that, like i told you before. 
use the recorded and looped tracks as your reference.
select the best parts and micro edit them into loops.
pt has audio quantization though.
|
| |
2nd July 2008
|
#3 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Mar 2008 Location: Watching over Brooklyn
Posts: 2,512
|
Program the midi first, then record the audio.
This is the best way. You can make variations of the midi track real easy. Plus you can make realtime adjustments to filters and other tweaks while recording back into Logic for more of a dynamic performance.
|
| |
2nd July 2008
|
#4 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Aug 2005 Location: san jose, califas
Posts: 2,610
|
logic doesn't have audio quantize? that sucks...cubase has had it for years. :p
[edit]
quick google turned this up for logic: LOGIC NOTES
i'd be shocked if the newer version doesn't allow something similar.
|
| |
3rd July 2008
|
#5 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Mar 2007 Location: West "Ma' ****in" Oakland
Posts: 557
Thread Starter | Quote:
Originally Posted by cynic logic doesn't have audio quantize? that sucks...cubase has had it for years. :p
[edit]
quick google turned this up for logic: LOGIC NOTES
i'd be shocked if the newer version doesn't allow something similar. | I havent even seen this in Logic 6, 7 or 8. But if you look at the images, that is a REAL old version of Logic. Im shocked its not there either.
|
| |
3rd July 2008
|
#6 | | 70% Coffee, 30% Beer
Joined: Dec 2006 Location: Quincy, MA
Posts: 9,123
|
Of course Logic has Quantize!
There are so many ways to do this;
If your recording the Audio, you can play 8 bar loops or whatever, and chop/position regions to create chorus, verses, etc....There are many ways to quantize, and it really depends on what your referring to, MIDI data, or Audio regions, sampling therom.........
I like to play 8 or whatever amount of bars that I can complete without sounding like a complete jackof, and I then chop the region so it starts on the down beat of the first measure [the ONE] ON Bar ONE in the Sequencer in Logic
Now I inch the region to start where I want it using "Shuffle" Left mode, which upon trimming the region, will scoot the audio file to the left determined by my sequencer setting, example; bars, beats, samples, ticks, frames, etc...I like samples myself]
So I snap the region to Bar ONE and I have quantized the audio to play at bar ONE. If I program some MIDI data with a MIDI region, and I want to stick the notes in a pre set quantized position, I choose the setting just above the Piano Roll and I can stick a MIDI note up a nat's ass! If I choose OFF, it wont automatically place the notes on the grid.
__________________ Adam Brass adam@dspdoctor.com DSPdoctor.com "Where High End is Still King"
__________________ "Any opinions above are worth exactly what you paid for them." Anonymous "If I find 10,000 ways something won't work, I haven't failed. I am not discouraged, because every wrong attempt discarded is another step forward. Thomas Edison RTFM |
| |
3rd July 2008
|
#7 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Jul 2003 Location: Fort Myers, FL
Posts: 613
|
Logic has had audio quantize since versio 3 or 4. I still use my old version 5 on pc and there is audio quantize. Get to know thw manual.
__________________ Quote: |
Originally Posted by lordnielson Heh, snobbery is hillarious... The difference between the two platforms (running optimally) is negligible. And if you really suck at what you do, the difference is the same.
"Exceeding our expectations left us in awe of our own recordings because they pretty much always took on a life of their own." Quote from Bob Olhsson on the magic of old school recording | |
| |
3rd July 2008
|
#8 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Mar 2007 Location: West "Ma' ****in" Oakland
Posts: 557
Thread Starter | Quote:
Originally Posted by Roc Mixwell Of course Logic has Quantize!
There are so many ways to do this;
If your recording the Audio, you can play 8 bar loops or whatever, and chop/position regions to create chorus, verses, etc....There are many ways to quantize, and it really depends on what your referring to, MIDI data, or Audio regions, sampling therom.........
I like to play 8 or whatever amount of bars that I can complete without sounding like a complete jackof, and I then chop the region so it starts on the down beat of the first measure [the ONE] ON Bar ONE in the Sequencer in Logic
Now I inch the region to start where I want it using "Shuffle" Left mode, which upon trimming the region, will scoot the audio file to the left determined by my sequencer setting, example; bars, beats, samples, ticks, frames, etc...I like samples myself]
So I snap the region to Bar ONE and I have quantized the audio to play at bar ONE. If I program some MIDI data with a MIDI region, and I want to stick the notes in a pre set quantized position, I choose the setting just above the Piano Roll and I can stick a MIDI note up a nat's ass! If I choose OFF, it wont automatically place the notes on the grid. | Well Im mainly talking about quantizing audio. Midi isnt a problem because THAT i can sync up and it tracks in perfectly on time. Its the audio i was talking about. I want to start playing in directly from my keyboards and modules but since im not a GREAT player, i want to get the audio down right as far as timing.
|
| |
3rd July 2008
|
#9 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Aug 2005 Location: san jose, califas
Posts: 2,610
| Quote:
Originally Posted by rallycapmusic I havent even seen this in Logic 6, 7 or 8. But if you look at the images, that is a REAL old version of Logic. Im shocked its not there either. | dude i think you need to peep your manual...seriously. in cubase it's done by defining hitpoints on the audio material, then quantizing that.
i'd expect logic does it in a similar fashion.
|
| |
3rd July 2008
|
#10 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Jul 2003 Location: Fort Myers, FL
Posts: 613
|
rallycapmusic,
I don't think there's any real way around this. You either need to improve your keyboard skills substantially or be satisfied tracking stuff one at a time. Depending on what instruments and audio interfacing you have you may be able to track to audio in one pass once you get your midi parts right.
For example, the Yamaha Motif with the mLan card would allow you to record into audio up to 16 tracks in one pass. If you have keyboards/samplers with multiple outs, you could assign one sound to each output and send stuff over in one or two passes.
Personally, I like having the ability to get my parts right with MIDI ... change things around. And doing it this way allows you to pick and choose which preamps/DIs you're going to pass your instruments through. I don't see a workaround if you're into using hardware... now if you're talking about softsynths then you could render to audio without as much fuss, but I like hardware and that's what I'm talking about.
Btw, Audio Quantize is useful and powerful, but I see it as a tool to fix small parts where the bulk of that take was great except for a not or two or three. MIDI quantize features are waaaay more useful and allows you to do way more.
|
| |
3rd July 2008
|
#11 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Apr 2004 Location: San Francisco, CA
Posts: 1,755
| Quote:
Originally Posted by cynic in cubase it's done by defining hitpoints on the audio material, then quantizing that.
i'd expect logic does it in a similar fashion. | It sure does.
|
| |
3rd July 2008
|
#12 | | Lives for gear
Joined: Mar 2007 Location: West "Ma' ****in" Oakland
Posts: 557
Thread Starter |
Understood guys. Will do. My synths have at least 4 outs a piece so i will just track through those, midi synced up. Thanks guys!
|
| | | |