High End DAW Shoot-out series?

Barish · 7th June 2007

MPG had a high end DAW shoot-out done at British Grove studios a while ago, with producer Pip Williams (who is an amazing producer who happened to have produced a few great tracks for my former band as well), Tony Platt, Haydn Bendall and co. and the video footage from that day was quite interesting.

Are you guys planning to do similar sessions across the country? Naturally none of the participants agree on the same result, but I believe this kind of sessions is very important for the participants to develop their audition skills and attention to detail. For there is always something we all fail to notice until we see somebody else pointing it out, no matter how careful we are. It would be a great learning experience.

Cheers,

B.

Tony Platt · 8th June 2007

It would be great to do this again but frankly it took so much organisation I can't see it becoming a reality!

What we are continuing is a policy of making comparisons - not to have 'shoot outs' to see what is best, but to find out which bits of gear do what so we can make informed decisions about what is best for what situation.

Personally I use comparison as my main method of evaluation on a daily basis because it gives me a valid starting point - so I think it is more to do with the philosophy of recording?

Tony

Barish · 9th June 2007

That's actually a better way of approaching the gear selection than shoot-outs indeed, so it's great to see MPG going one step ahead of the rest of us in this never-ending, excuse my Turkish, pissing contest. Looking forward to those sessions.

Thanks for the information, Tony.

By the way, for those who haven't seen the shoot-out video, here it is:

MPG event 2005 comparison with analoge and digital recording

B.

jupiter8 · 15th June 2007

I'm curious about what converters were used on the Nuendo and Protools rig. I don't think it's mentioned anywhere.

Tony Platt · 15th June 2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by jupiter8

I'm curious about what converters were used on the Nuendo and Protools rig. I don't think it's mentioned anywhere.

The Nuendo had Prism converters and the Protools was using the Digidesign HD192.

7th June 2007	#1
Barish Lives for gear Joined: Sep 2004 Location: Istanbul, Turkey Posts: 1,803 Thread Starter	High End DAW Shoot-out series? MPG had a high end DAW shoot-out done at British Grove studios a while ago, with producer Pip Williams (who is an amazing producer who happened to have produced a few great tracks for my former band as well), Tony Platt, Haydn Bendall and co. and the video footage from that day was quite interesting. Are you guys planning to do similar sessions across the country? Naturally none of the participants agree on the same result, but I believe this kind of sessions is very important for the participants to develop their audition skills and attention to detail. For there is always something we all fail to notice until we see somebody else pointing it out, no matter how careful we are. It would be a great learning experience. Cheers, B.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Best summing mixer for a high end DAW?	Muso	High end	141	21st April 2011 02:43 PM
Low End Tube Mic Shoot out?	kenm	Low End Theory	2	11th May 2007 11:04 PM
How many High End studio owners live the High End life?	Jules	So much gear, so little time!	69	20th April 2007 02:14 PM
High End DAW??? (interfaces)	teddy07x	High end	54	15th October 2006 07:25 PM
High-end tubes replacement for high-end gears	GYang	High end	7	16th September 2006 01:10 PM

8th June 2007	#2
Tony Platt Special guest Joined: May 2007 Posts: 39	It would be great to do this again but frankly it took so much organisation I can't see it becoming a reality! What we are continuing is a policy of making comparisons - not to have 'shoot outs' to see what is best, but to find out which bits of gear do what so we can make informed decisions about what is best for what situation. Personally I use comparison as my main method of evaluation on a daily basis because it gives me a valid starting point - so I think it is more to do with the philosophy of recording? Tony

9th June 2007	#3
Barish Lives for gear Joined: Sep 2004 Location: Istanbul, Turkey Posts: 1,803 Thread Starter	That's actually a better way of approaching the gear selection than shoot-outs indeed, so it's great to see MPG going one step ahead of the rest of us in this never-ending, excuse my Turkish, pissing contest. Looking forward to those sessions. Thanks for the information, Tony. By the way, for those who haven't seen the shoot-out video, here it is: MPG event 2005 comparison with analoge and digital recording B.

15th June 2007	#4
jupiter8 Lives for gear Joined: Feb 2006 Posts: 1,114	I'm curious about what converters were used on the Nuendo and Protools rig. I don't think it's mentioned anywhere.