Login / Register
 
Apogee I/O fan noise? Other converter options...?
New Reply
Subscribe
Bob800
Thread Starter
#1
8th November 2010
Old 8th November 2010
  #1
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 530

Thread Starter
Bob800 is offline
Apogee I/O fan noise? Other converter options...?

How loud is the Apogee I/O fan noise actually? I really would like to buy this piece of equipment, but I read someone saying it´s about as loud as Mac Pro and that´s definitely a dealbreaker for me. Fan noise drives me crazy!

Regardles, I´m going to buy the Symphony 64 card and I might just get a Rosetta 200 for it, which is totally quiet right?

But is there other better converters you would suggest to pair up with the Symphony 64 card?
Bob800
Thread Starter
#2
10th November 2010
Old 10th November 2010
  #2
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 530

Thread Starter
Bob800 is offline
No info about the fan noise? Or other converter suggestions?
#3
10th November 2010
Old 10th November 2010
  #3
Lives for gear
 
markham's Avatar
 
Joined: Jun 2009
Location: No longer in Pago Pago! Now in Durham, NC.
Posts: 1,193

markham is online now
No idea about fan noise, as I haven't used this model.

For other converter options, I'd look at Metric Halo, especially the ULN-8 or LIO-8. There are several threads about the units here. Just do a search. They won't work with a Symphony card, but neither will anything else that isn't an Apogee. Metric Halo makes some kick-ass stuff.
__________________
Still on OSX 10.6.8 | Still on Logic Pro 9.1.5 | Metric Halo LIO-8/4P | I also like guitars a lot.
#4
10th November 2010
Old 10th November 2010
  #4
70% Coffee, 30% Beer
 
Doc Mixwell's Avatar
 
Joined: Dec 2006
Location: Quincy, MA
Posts: 10,284

Send a message via Skype™ to Doc Mixwell
Doc Mixwell is offline
The Fan noise is in the Symphony is not as loud of a noise as Mac Pro.

I have both here at the studio, in our climate controlled machine room, where they are both free to be as noisy as they want. Having the box away from control position is not a problem for me, since every aspect of control with the unit can be done through M2 with either a USB connection or connection to a Symphony 64 card.

- After much testing and spending time in there -

It think it is quieter, to my hearing and attention skills.

If you want these analog to digital and digital to analog converters to operate properly - they need to be kept cool.

To some the whisper quiet fan breaks deals, which I can understand - wanting a silently optimized control position - but the fan noise when this unit is inside a rack does not pose a problem for me at all. Again, to others it may be unfortunate. You can't please everyone now can you!

And - Yes, the Rosetta 200 does not have a fan. And - Yes, only Apogee Legacy X and Rosetta Series [Along with the new Symphony I/O] with work directly with the Symphony 64 card.
Bob800
Thread Starter
#5
12th November 2010
Old 12th November 2010
  #5
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 530

Thread Starter
Bob800 is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by markham View Post
No idea about fan noise, as I haven't used this model.

For other converter options, I'd look at Metric Halo, especially the ULN-8 or LIO-8. There are several threads about the units here. Just do a search. They won't work with a Symphony card, but neither will anything else that isn't an Apogee. Metric Halo makes some kick-ass stuff.
Yes, I´ve looked into Metric Halo and they seem to make good stuff, but firewire soundcards are a dealbreaker for me. I want PCI-E.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Roc Mixwell View Post
The Fan noise is in the Symphony is not as loud of a noise as Mac Pro.

I have both here at the studio, in our climate controlled machine room, where they are both free to be as noisy as they want. Having the box away from control position is not a problem for me, since every aspect of control with the unit can be done through M2 with either a USB connection or connection to a Symphony 64 card.

- After much testing and spending time in there -

It think it is quieter, to my hearing and attention skills.

If you want these analog to digital and digital to analog converters to operate properly - they need to be kept cool.

To some the whisper quiet fan breaks deals, which I can understand - wanting a silently optimized control position - but the fan noise when this unit is inside a rack does not pose a problem for me at all. Again, to others it may be unfortunate. You can't please everyone now can you!

And - Yes, the Rosetta 200 does not have a fan. And - Yes, only Apogee Legacy X and Rosetta Series [Along with the new Symphony I/O] with work directly with the Symphony 64 card.
I can´t put the Symphony I/O into another room so it seems like it´s going to be a dealbreaker for me. Shame.

Oh well, probably going to go with the Rosetta 200 then. It can´t sound that much worse than the Symphony I/O?
GCL
#6
12th November 2010
Old 12th November 2010
  #6
GCL
Gear addict
 
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 460

GCL is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bob800 View Post
Yes, I´ve looked into Metric Halo and they seem to make good stuff, but firewire soundcards are a dealbreaker for me. I want PCI-E.



I can´t put the Symphony I/O into another room so it seems like it´s going to be a dealbreaker for me. Shame.

Oh well, probably going to go with the Rosetta 200 then. It can´t sound that much worse than the Symphony I/O?
I agree, fan noise on the Symphony I/O is too loud for quiet mix rooms. I'll have to look elsewhere, or figure something out. I really wanted to get the Apogee...

I wonder that if you are going to have only a single card installed (Analog in/out), if you can disable the fan. Apogee says the fan speed is variable, but after it's on for a while it never slows down or gets quieter. Same as a Mac Pro...
#7
12th November 2010
Old 12th November 2010
  #7
Gear maniac
 
Joined: Feb 2006
Location: Santa Monica, CA
Posts: 190

Clawson is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by GCL View Post
I agree, fan noise on the Symphony I/O is too loud for quiet mix rooms. I'll have to look elsewhere, or figure something out. I really wanted to get the Apogee...

I wonder that if you are going to have only a single card installed (Analog in/out), if you can disable the fan. Apogee says the fan speed is variable, but after it's on for a while it never slows down or gets quieter. Same as a Mac Pro...
When you set up Symphony I/O, where was it in your room that the fan noise was so loud? I have been in a few studios now with Symphony I/O in the control room and no one said anything about the fan. In one studio he had Symphony I/O sitting right in the middle of his desk between his monitors.

Chris Lawson
Apogee Electronics
#8
12th November 2010
Old 12th November 2010
  #8
Gear nut
 
Joined: Jul 2004
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 131

twbrzkdm007 is offline
after installing the 2nd release of the Symp i/o software, I can report that the fan noise has improved somewhat from release 1. Maybe this coincides with the much cooler temps here in LA and in my control room so this might not be definitive... but I can work for a couple of hours without the fan even jumping on (and boy, the sound of silence is beautiful!). With release 1 the fan would jump on and then never stop even when the ambient temp wasn't that high. So hopefully the software controlling the fan's behavior will be tweaked more so that that the noise issue might become mute.
Bob800
Thread Starter
#9
12th November 2010
Old 12th November 2010
  #9
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 530

Thread Starter
Bob800 is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by Clawson View Post
When you set up Symphony I/O, where was it in your room that the fan noise was so loud? I have been in a few studios now with Symphony I/O in the control room and no one said anything about the fan. In one studio he had Symphony I/O sitting right in the middle of his desk between his monitors.

Chris Lawson
Apogee Electronics
Maybe some people aren´t that strick about fan noise? I know many engineers who aren´t very strick and precise with mixing either although they are paid a lot and have the best gear. tutt

I have a Mac Pro, iMac and an external hard drive humming in my room. Those three are already driving me nuts. Luckily I can turn the iMac + external hard drive off while mixing, but I don´t want anymore noise in my room, Mac Pro noise is enough.

It really puzzles me why such a high end company like Apogee would put a fan in such a high end gear?

To me it seems like a "turd in a punch bowl". Shame, really wanted to get this.

But people, please reassure me that Rosetta 200 sound isn´t much worse than the Symphony I/O!
#10
12th November 2010
Old 12th November 2010
  #10
Gear maniac
 
Joined: Feb 2006
Location: Santa Monica, CA
Posts: 190

Clawson is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bob800 View Post
Maybe some people aren´t that strick about fan noise? I know many engineers who aren´t very strick and precise with mixing either although they are paid a lot and have the best gear. tutt

I have a Mac Pro, iMac and an external hard drive humming in my room. Those three are already driving me nuts. Luckily I can turn the iMac + external hard drive off while mixing, but I don´t want anymore noise in my room, Mac Pro noise is enough.

It really puzzles me why such a high end company like Apogee would put a fan in such a high end gear?

To me it seems like a "turd in a punch bowl". Shame, really wanted to get this.

But people, please reassure me that Rosetta 200 sound isn´t much worse than the Symphony I/O!
Hi end audio requires hi end components, often these components run very hot and need to be cooled off. We didn't just add a fan for no reason.
Also, as Adam mentioned in his post, it is definitely not as loud as the Fan in a Mac Pro. I would also go on to say that in a rack, you would not even notice it at all.


Chris Lawson
Apogee Electronics
#11
13th November 2010
Old 13th November 2010
  #11
Gear maniac
 
Joined: Aug 2005
Location: Germany
Posts: 217

trancekid is offline
that probably depends on the general noise in the control room. I have the Symphony i/o with 2 cards installed in a rack maybe 1 meter away from me and the fan turns on after 5 min and is clearly there as it is the only gear in my CR with a fan and I find it pretty annoying tbh.

everything else which is noisy/has a fan is in a machine room and i seriously think about putting the symphony there as well. unfortunalely i got all the cabling done to have it in the CR. I really love the sound and the features of the symphony but the fan really turns me off.

I was the one who said that it's as loud as a mac pro and i have to take that back. i just did a comparison and my mac pro is clearly louder, but still, you can easily hear the fan in the symphony if it's the only gear with a fan in your CR.

also mine has a bit of a somewhat unsteady high resonating tinnitus-like sound to it, is that with every unit ?


---
Bob800
Thread Starter
#12
13th November 2010
Old 13th November 2010
  #12
Lives for gear
 
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 530

Thread Starter
Bob800 is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by Clawson View Post
Hi end audio requires hi end components, often these components run very hot and need to be cooled off. We didn't just add a fan for no reason.

Chris Lawson
Apogee Electronics
Hmm... so then Rosetta 200 does not have high-end components?


Quote:
Originally Posted by trancekid View Post
also mine has a bit of a somewhat unsteady high resonating tinnitus-like sound to it, is that with every unit ?


---
Wow, that´s even worse.

I bought couple of MacBook Pros with SSD and tinnitus sound was coming from them, drove me nuts and I had no choise but to return them. Then I bought a MBP with HDD and no tinnitus sound. Of course I can´t sure where the sound came from.
#13
15th November 2010
Old 15th November 2010
  #13
Gear maniac
 
outcastrising's Avatar
 
Joined: Dec 2006
Location: Kansas
Posts: 183

outcastrising is offline
With the second release I cannot even hear the fan. I complained to Apogee about the issue and apparently they listened as it is a non issue now for me at least.
#14
15th November 2010
Old 15th November 2010
  #14
Lives for gear
 
The MPCist's Avatar
 
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 4,644

The MPCist is offline
Last week, a friend and I did a Symphony I/O v. X-series A/B test with the Symphony on the side of the SSL 9KJ console.... no issue with fan noise at all. And this is with the computer/other interfaces in the machine room as well.

The one we tested was running firmware release 2.
__________________
THE MPCIST
GCL
#15
15th November 2010
Old 15th November 2010
  #15
GCL
Gear addict
 
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 460

GCL is offline
Chris – the unit is a beautiful piece. Many may not want to have it in a rack. Many don't even have rack gear anymore. I don't, not a single piece. In a quiet composer studio the fan is too loud and distracting. Might have been a better idea to put in 2 fans running at half speed...
I'll be looking at the Ensemble again.
#16
15th November 2010
Old 15th November 2010
  #16
Lives for gear
 
The MPCist's Avatar
 
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 4,644

The MPCist is offline
Uh.... I don't understand the fan talk. It's not that loud. It's there but not that audible. I'm sitting here with a Symphony sitting right under my AWS900 not 3 feet from me and all I hear is the MacPro sitting 10 feet away!
#17
19th December 2010
Old 19th December 2010
  #17
Gear interested
 
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 2

sascha.victoria is offline
I just got my new Symphony I/O and there's definitely fan noise. My old Apogee system was dead silent compared to this. Oh right, there was no fan in there. I would describe this sound as a dying hard dive. Spinning faster, slower, faster, slower, faster, slower, etc... vroom vroom.

My question for the people that say they have no fan noise: is your unit in a rack or is it sitting on the floor / table by itself? Currently my unit is in a rack with about 3 spaces below it 1 space above but none of the other gear in the rack is on. I think I'm going to try taking it out of the track and setting it on the concrete floor to see if that does anything...

p.s. yes I have the most current firmware installed.
#18
19th December 2010
Old 19th December 2010
  #18
Lives for gear
 
The MPCist's Avatar
 
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 4,644

The MPCist is offline
Quote:
Originally Posted by sascha.victoria View Post
My question for the people that say they have no fan noise: is your unit in a rack or is it sitting on the floor / table by itself?
Mine's sitting in a rack under the console.... Since I'm leaning over the console, I didn't hear any noise at first but I guess it's there but I don't notice it at all.
#19
19th December 2010
Old 19th December 2010
  #19
Gear interested
 
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 2

sascha.victoria is offline
Just out of curiosity, does the AWS9000 or its power supply have any internal fans or does it use heat sinks?
#20
19th December 2010
Old 19th December 2010
  #20
Lives for gear
 
syntax's Avatar
 
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 518

syntax is offline
Why is firewire a deal breaker? The ULN-8 is totally solid on firewire.
#21
19th December 2010
Old 19th December 2010
  #21
Gear maniac
 
Kaneepa's Avatar
 
Joined: Feb 2003
Location: Milano, Italy
Posts: 166

Send a message via ICQ to Kaneepa
Kaneepa is offline
I returned mine for fan noise.. Too much for keeping it in control room.
Exchanged for another avid hd io (4 of them are already in machine room)
Much lower fan noise...

Regards

Michele
#22
9th June 2012
Old 9th June 2012
  #22
Lives for gear
 
Melgueil's Avatar
 
Joined: Dec 2007
Location: Montpellier, France
Posts: 1,246

Melgueil is offline
I will not tolerate noise in the CR, as in ANY. I worked way too hard to get it whisper quiet. Fan noise is an absolute deal breaker.

ULN-8 and be done with it.
Cdlt
__________________
Enfin... tout le monde a une Rolex. Si à cinquante ans, on n'a pas une Rolex, on a quand même raté sa vie !"
- Jacques Séguéla -
#23
9th June 2012
Old 9th June 2012
  #23
70% Coffee, 30% Beer
 
Doc Mixwell's Avatar
 
Joined: Dec 2006
Location: Quincy, MA
Posts: 10,284

Send a message via Skype™ to Doc Mixwell
Doc Mixwell is offline
I have a VERY quiet studio. VERY

My Apogee sits less than a 1 ft, from my mix spot.

I have one 8x8 card inside it.

The Fan has never even been heard....once, in over a year's worth of use.

If it was, it was not annoying anyone around me

The Fan kicks up louder when you put another module inside the unit.

Apogee has a mod kit that helps to reduce the fan from kicking up.

Contact them, they are very helpful.
#24
9th June 2012
Old 9th June 2012
  #24
Gear addict
 
nicpope's Avatar
 
Joined: Jul 2007
Location: San Francisco
Posts: 461

nicpope is offline
All this talk about fan noise and nobody mentioned building a machine room?
#25
9th August 2012
Old 9th August 2012
  #25
www.jellimusic.com
 
csauter's Avatar
 
Joined: Nov 2010
Location: New York
Posts: 115

Send a message via AIM to csauter Send a message via Skype™ to csauter
csauter is offline
okay, so now with the latest Symphony Release that's supposed to take care of all this fan noise, what is the FINAL verdict from Symphony owners using the Symphony I/O in their control room with the latest firmware installed?? How loud is the fan now... tolerable (like a nice quite Macbook Pro Retina) or unacceptable?? Is it or is it not an issue anymore???

FINAL VERDICT!! =)


-Love Chris
__________________
--
SPREAD THE J.E.L.L.i. !!
http://www.jellimusic.com
#26
13th August 2012
Old 13th August 2012
  #26
Gear maniac
 
bakerman's Avatar
 
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 290

bakerman is offline
Am running 4.2 on Snow Leopard. Verdict is 'vroom vroom' since installing the 2nd module. Was quieter than the MacPro beforehand with single module. Waiting for the mod kit but not holding my breathe
#27
14th August 2012
Old 14th August 2012
  #27
www.jellimusic.com
 
csauter's Avatar
 
Joined: Nov 2010
Location: New York
Posts: 115

Send a message via AIM to csauter Send a message via Skype™ to csauter
csauter is offline
thanks

Thanks for that Bakerman... i appreciate it.. I don't have the base unit but i just bought the 16 analog in card, and i'll leave it at that then... lol

Anyone with the modkit have any thoughts to add?? 1 or two modules??
#28
15th August 2012
Old 15th August 2012
  #28
Gear maniac
 
bakerman's Avatar
 
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 290

bakerman is offline
with regret I've decided to return the 2nd Apogee module. Looking for alternatives for a 32 out system.
#29
9th September 2012
Old 9th September 2012
  #29
Gear interested
 
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 2

skorko is offline
My Symphony IO sounds like a truck idling in my control room
#30
9th September 2012
Old 9th September 2012
  #30
Lives for gear
 
Melgueil's Avatar
 
Joined: Dec 2007
Location: Montpellier, France
Posts: 1,246

Melgueil is offline
Lord ...

I just built an ISO box to get rid of the whirling of my CPU (she gets hot under the coller when she breaks a sweat). Checked my CR yesterday - near dead silent - once again. I guess this issue is with the two modules only, but that was the route I would (have) consider(ed). SIO is a gorgeous system but it would have to locked away in a machine room, or ISO rack - so it would seem. Anyway ....appreciate the feedback.

Cdlt

Last edited by Melgueil; 9th September 2012 at 07:43 AM.. Reason: Change word
New Reply Submit Thread to Facebook Facebook  Submit Thread to Twitter Twitter  Submit Thread to LinkedIn LinkedIn  Submit Thread to Google+ Google+ 
 
Thread Tools
Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Similar Threads
Thread
Thread Starter / Forum
Replies
api2500 / Music Computers
8
papiel / Music Computers
11
oldgearguy / High end
2

Forum Jump

SEO by vBSEO ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.