Thank you Mr. Bob Katz

[KRStudio]

I second a "thank you" to Mr. Katz. Both here and on the Samplitude/Sequoia forum he is as nice as can be, and freely gives any advice at any time! Thank you sir.

Jeff

[screwtop]

...and a "same here" from me - I got the first edition and dip into it all the time, finding new things or re-learning things I already "knew".

It carefully debunks a number of erroneous "common knowledge" practices that never sat right with me: peak-normalising song-by-song, or tracking as close to 0 dB FS so as not to waste any bits, for example. I was impressed at how thorough his treatment of the digital domain is - it's really a different beast from analog in so many ways.

The inclusion of the fold-out Carnegie Hall chart inside the front cover (showing the relationships between notes, frequencies, instruments, etc.) says a lot: you can tell he always has the impact of/on the music in mind when he's discussing the technicalities. Especially great stuff on monitor setup and calibration, the K-System of course, jitter, dither, DSP losses, dynamics, EQ, and radio-readiness. Important things for tracking and mixing, not just mastering.

Thank you, Mr Katz.
--
Chris

[lerone]

Yes, thankyou Mr Katz, easily my favourite book of all time. Nice one! Will be purchasing a new Carnegie chart to get framed for my studio at some point soon.

Lerone

[Joe_caithness]

Very nice when I corrosponded with him recnetly.

Not going to get all teary eyed about it, because "art and science" is only one persons opinion, but it's often brought out on ear rests at Subsequent

[Table Of Tone]

Yep!
It a "Thanks Mr. Bob Katz!" from me too!

Super helpful and a world of knowledge for sure!

[JSG]

Yes indeed! Thank you Mr. Katz. And yes, it is "Art & Science" and everyone has their own understanding and opinions, however, Mr. Katz has a way of explaining and delivering his knowledge and experience that makes me trust him, and his opinions. Going from years of analog only to digital (DAW) about two years ago, Bob's book helped me immensely.

[j_j]

Bob Katz for President!

Seriously, I appreciate people who are willing to spread knowlege. I try to do it myself, but not in a mastering setting, for the most part.

[bob katz]

Originally Posted by j_j

Bob Katz for President!

Seriously, I appreciate people who are willing to spread knowlege. I try to do it myself, but not in a mastering setting, for the most part.

I'm not running! Speaking of spreading knowledge, the previous poster, JJ (Jim Johnston) will be spreading his knowledge in several workshops at the NY AES convention this fall. Hope to see him (and you all!) there! I'll be on a workshop on the last day (Monday) about the loudness wars, with several nice participants, including Bob Ludwig.

Take care and so many thanks for your support, hope I don't trip up!


Bob

[streetbeats]

Originally Posted by bob katz

I'll be on a workshop on the last day (Monday) about the loudness wars, with several nice participants, including Bob Ludwig.

+1 on the thanks Bob, and a request in the context of that workshop you mention - pop by here and tell us how it went?

[TwoTrack]

Originally Posted by bob katz

I'm not running! Speaking of spreading knowledge, the previous poster, JJ (Jim Johnston) will be spreading his knowledge in several workshops at the NY AES convention this fall. Hope to see him (and you all!) there! I'll be on a workshop on the last day (Monday) about the loudness wars, with several nice participants, including Bob Ludwig.

Take care and so many thanks for your support, hope I don't trip up!


Bob

I had the privilege of working with Bob on some projects at Chesky Records back in the 90s. He is a terrific guy and this book only hints at the depth of his knowledge. He also has a very good sense of humor. This book is simply essential reading.

Great to see you are on this board Bob.

Lee

[Axon]

Originally Posted by bob katz

I'm not running! Speaking of spreading knowledge, the previous poster, JJ (Jim Johnston) will be spreading his knowledge in several workshops at the NY AES convention this fall. Hope to see him (and you all!) there! I'll be on a workshop on the last day (Monday) about the loudness wars, with several nice participants, including Bob Ludwig.

... which, unfortunately, collides with one of jj's workshops. Decisions, decisions. ::

[j_j]

Originally Posted by Axon

... which, unfortunately, collides with one of jj's workshops. Decisions, decisions. ::

Yeah. Which is why I'm not doing the "TURN IT DOWN" workshop as well.

As to "TURN IT DOWN" I would only add to the phrase "turn it down" a word suggesting that I am wishing for a deity to condemn something.

I suggest you hit Bob's workshop. You already know about memory levels, etc, I think. If not, I can give you the 3 minute version, and my part of that presentation will become clear, and without a comb filter in sight.

[j_j]

Originally Posted by bob katz

I'm not running!

See? This proves that you SHOULD be President, you don't want the job. Seriously, I'm convinced that anyone who wants that job is, err, (error, propriety and language exceeded!).

After the workshop, I'll try to get Rick Chinn to put the deck for it (as well as some others) up at PowerPoint Presentations from recent (or not so recent) meetings. alongside the rest of my tutorial decks.

[Axon]

"If elected, I refuse to serve. POW!"

[korbes]

Mastering Audio is a great book! The content is great but I also very much enjoy the layout and illustrations.
Plus the horizontal format is wonderful; it stays open and doesn't collapse (shut? sorry, not a native speaker ;-)) when it lies on the table.
Thought out through and through :-)

[Dicebox]

I got mine just a few weeks ago....like it very much! Without question one of my favourite books I have

[marcenavia]

Yes, thank you Bob.

A few months ago I bought his book after reading it I decided to do just mastering.

He is always open to answer questions, no words to thank him.

If in the future I get my clients are happy with my work, it will be thanks to Bob.

[thehightenor]

I don't think Bob posts here anymore.

tht

[Alécio Costa]

It is a pity he is no longer here.
Some of the best advising concerning mastering was taken from him.

[teknatronik]

Originally Posted by thehightenor

I don't think Bob posts here anymore.

tht

he just posted? lol

[Tom Higgins]

Originally Posted by teknatronik

he just posted? lol

Check the dates

[teknatronik]

Originally Posted by Tom Higgins

Check the dates

oh wow! I am sorry for that then, should have looked!

[gtzack4]

I am about to buy this book and was wondering if there are any major differences in the first and second editions?

[Babaluma]

Third edition should be out soon. I'd hang on for that. I have the first and the second edition. There are a few differences, but nothing that would require owning both.

[Rick Hoekman]

Originally Posted by Babaluma

Third edition should be out soon. I'd hang on for that. I have the first and the second edition. There are a few differences, but nothing that would require owning both.

Gregg, do you have any idea when it will be released? I've heard him mentioning this on Square Cad podcast last year.

[PBM]

Originally Posted by Babaluma

Third edition should be out soon. I'd hang on for that. I have the first and the second edition. There are a few differences, but nothing that would require owning both.

My daughter tells me that the photo of the two of us is better in the 2nd edition; firstly because she's no longer a baby; secondly because you can't see my knees.

Cheers,

Eric

[Rick Hoekman]

Originally Posted by PBM

My daughter tells me that the photo of the two of us is better in the 2nd edition; firstly because she's no longer a baby; secondly because you can't see my knees.

Cheers,

Eric

[DigiGal]

Great book and reference, thanks Bob, eagerly awaiting Vol. 3

[Babaluma]

Nope, no idea, just going on what Bob said in that SquareCad podcast a while back. Maybe Eric knows more?