cheapest soundcard with the best converters - Page 4

Acoustic Cloud · 28th November 2006

sorry, just found several sources,....yep.

RusRant · 28th November 2006

Yeah, but the deals on these cards right now are great. Plus it's being replaced with the 1616M. So far it (1616M) seems to have somewhat better pres, but overall less inputs. Otherwise same converters. For $149 new, the 1212M is an outstanding deal.

jslevin · 28th November 2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by moon_unit

People put way too much stock in the "D" side of the equation rather than the "A." And most of these PCI cards just have very poor performing analog stages. Most of them have harmonic distortion and speed/slew rate specs that are bordering on unacceptable levels for professional audio. And unfortunately, everything you record will have to go through that before it gets "converted." It's a shame.
.

Yeah. Anything that has analog signal going directly into a PCI card, where the signal path is sharing space with CPUs and hard drives and power supplies and fans, is automatically out as far as I'm concerned. I mean, it's just an incredibly dumb idea.

JSL

Acoustic Cloud · 28th November 2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by jslevin

Yeah. Anything that has analog signal going directly into a PCI card, where the signal path is sharing space with CPUs and hard drives and power supplies and fans, is automatically out as far as I'm concerned. I mean, it's just an incredibly dumb idea.

JSL

I never thought of that.

hmmm..

the 1616m seems like a good substitute though. The 1820m always sounded very good, as long as you didnt touch any patchmix settings!!

I am surprised that newer cards are still coming out pci. Arent the newer boxes not really needing this?

I am not a PC geek (yet), so I guess I am missing the benefit.

Bassmankr · 29th November 2006

If you have an interface with a breakout box/rack unit the converters are away from the computer and all that electrical noise so a PCI interface is no big deal and will move data faster in and out than a firewire connection (one less thing to go through as the firewire is usually tied to the PCI buss on the motherboard). You are right about all these cheap cards having a weak analog circuit before the converters, this is where you get what you pay for. The converter chips are cheap in comparison to the analog stage for the manufacturer.

sekim · 1st December 2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by RusRant

I only use the wdm drivers with the 1212m, and am able to get very low latency. But Asio? I don't bother, to glitchy at lower settings.

I've not had this issue. ASIO on the 1820M has been rock solid here after I sorted out which PCI slot to put the card on. I've run 30 track projects with piles of FX's and three VSTi's at 2ms and it worked fine. I don't do that as a normal practice but it's nice to know I can if needed.

sekim · 1st December 2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bassmankr

... a PCI interface is no big deal and will move data faster in and out than a firewire connection (one less thing to go through as the firewire is usually tied to the PCI buss on the motherboard)...

Be aware that the cable connecting the breakout box to host card on the 1820 is proprietary protocol firewire. So the 1820M is a proprietary firewire box and it's PCI card a proprietary firewire adapter as far as data flow is concerned...

Bassmankr · 2nd December 2006

Actually its a cat 5e cable from the converters/breakout box on the 1820M to the PCI card, so its ethernet not firewire. I replaced the furnished 15 footer with a 25 foot cat 6e which works fine. The PCI card has a firewire jack but it's just a pass through (same thing you would find on a motherboard) which is only useful if you don't use your motherboard's (no audio goes through it). I posted the link to the E-MU unofficial forum in a prior post in this thread. Although there are lots of fanboys that hang, there is still balanced (both the good and bad things) info on the cards to be found there. It's a good place to start with your research before spending your dollars.

RusRant · 2nd December 2006

Quote:

I've not had this issue. ASIO on the 1820M has been rock solid here after I sorted out which PCI slot to put the card on. I've run 30 track projects with piles of FX's and three VSTi's at 2ms and it worked fine. I don't do that as a normal practice but it's nice to know I can if needed.

I have tried everything and still no luck. I gave up as I really don't need the asio drivers anyway and I'm able to get 2ms-6ms of latency with the WDM drivers depending on software. I've heard many people have had no issues with them, I guess I've been one of the unlucky ones. But it's a great card regardless.

sekim · 19th December 2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bassmankr

Actually its a cat 5e cable from the converters/breakout box on the 1820M to the PCI card, so its ethernet not firewire...

The protocol itself is proprietary firewire, they chose to implement it via cat5 wiring is all.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Cheapest soundcard with ADAT and S/PDIF I/O	siegfried	Low End Theory	6	10th May 2006 01:36 AM
Pro Tools converters into RME soundcard?	Sput	High end	1	15th April 2006 07:43 PM
Soundcard/Converters: Bang for the buck	StefanColson	So much gear, so little time!	6	12th February 2006 09:40 PM
ad/da Soundcard Converters Advice	DP40oz	Low End Theory	7	24th October 2005 05:35 PM
Can/Do I keep my soundcard as I get new A/D D/A converters?	jebjerome	So much gear, so little time!	3	18th May 2004 09:57 AM

28th November 2006	#91
Acoustic Cloud Lives for gear Joined: Jun 2006 Location: around the corner Posts: 1,990	sorry, just found several sources,....yep.

28th November 2006	#92
RusRant Lives for gear Joined: Jul 2006 Location: B'ham, AL Posts: 998	Yeah, but the deals on these cards right now are great. Plus it's being replaced with the 1616M. So far it (1616M) seems to have somewhat better pres, but overall less inputs. Otherwise same converters. For $149 new, the 1212M is an outstanding deal.

29th November 2006	#95
Bassmankr Lives for gear Joined: Jul 2005 Posts: 1,909	If you have an interface with a breakout box/rack unit the converters are away from the computer and all that electrical noise so a PCI interface is no big deal and will move data faster in and out than a firewire connection (one less thing to go through as the firewire is usually tied to the PCI buss on the motherboard). You are right about all these cheap cards having a weak analog circuit before the converters, this is where you get what you pay for. The converter chips are cheap in comparison to the analog stage for the manufacturer.

2nd December 2006	#98
Bassmankr Lives for gear Joined: Jul 2005 Posts: 1,909	Actually its a cat 5e cable from the converters/breakout box on the 1820M to the PCI card, so its ethernet not firewire. I replaced the furnished 15 footer with a 25 foot cat 6e which works fine. The PCI card has a firewire jack but it's just a pass through (same thing you would find on a motherboard) which is only useful if you don't use your motherboard's (no audio goes through it). I posted the link to the E-MU unofficial forum in a prior post in this thread. Although there are lots of fanboys that hang, there is still balanced (both the good and bad things) info on the cards to be found there. It's a good place to start with your research before spending your dollars.