compressor pedal

feyshay · 1st September 2005, 05:59 PM

I need a compressor pedal. I know this is not necessarily the best thing for my Fender Super Reverb, taking away the dynamics, but I want one anyway. I decided to try out the Line 6 Constrictor and bought it to mess around with, knowing I can return it in 30 days.
What I'm wondering is would it be worth getting something twice the price like the Carl Martin Compressor/Limiter, which gives more control over the variables.
Also note that I plan on getting a good compressor/equalizer (probably the Toft EC-1/ or ATC-2 or Joe Meek's One or Two Q) in the future.
Would it be worth ordering the Carl Martin from a company in order to try out. Will it make a big difference. Of note, I play a Les Paul Standard.
Thanks for any and all suggestions.

pan60 · 1st September 2005, 06:39 PM

i have tried a few, and used a older MXR dyna comp for some time.
when i plugged into the Carl Martin Compressor i bought it.
i like the control, and it dose not have that drastic sag or pump some have.
it dose squeeze a lot, i do wish the compression was not so drastic up front, when you first turn the comp knob you get a lot of compression, but it is the sweetest compressor i have seen in a stomp box.
it has become a mainstay for me.
i play a G&L ASAT Classic and mostly older fender amps, ( so you have a reference ).
i have become a fan of Carl Martin products as a result, and picked up a few more of their box's, before my Carl Martin Compressor i had not found a stomp box i was will to use regularly.

sonic dogg · 1st September 2005, 06:50 PM

The Carl Martin is the best. I love the 'busy' light...

JMURRAY16 · 1st September 2005, 07:30 PM

The Carl Martin Compressor is a good unit, but there are better units out there now.
Firstly, the Keeley Compressor - terrific.
Next the Analogman Compressor - Analog Mike always makes great stuff.
I even like the Menatone unit a bit better on guitar.
Any other questions please let me know.

feyshay · 1st September 2005, 07:40 PM

Anybody try the Line 6? I know it just came out recently.
Don't the pickups on the Les Paul run pretty hot? I always have to keep my volume knobs down to about 4 when I use pedals. Should that be a factor in the decision as to which compressor pedal I go with?
I was on the Keeley and analogman pages before and was intrigued, especially by the Comprosser. A couple hundred is a lot for a compressor pedal, no?

Amplove · 1st September 2005, 08:40 PM

Menatone makes a compressor pedal for guitar that's based on an 1176! That's pretty bitchen. Black Dog anyone?

j.

neve1073 · 1st September 2005, 09:06 PM

I sometimes use a boss compressor pedal with 65 super reverb. The mxr dynacomp is very good too of course.

For a certain squishy sound you need a compressor. But I have mixed feelings about compressor pedals. If I have one in my rack I will use it (on a gig) constantly with subtle settings, but for the music I play I'm pretty sure it sounds better w/o. I know that doesn't make sense which is why I usually don't put a compressor in my pedalboard anymore. It all depends what sound you are going for.

I haven't tried the many other compressor pedals.

TAVD · 1st September 2005, 09:15 PM

Here's a few more to check out:
Barber tone press
Demeter compulator
Aphex punch factory
Janglebox
EH Blackfinger or Whitefinger

And my fav, the HBE compressor.

retropete · 1st September 2005, 09:15 PM

I love my Keeley Compressor. When I got it, I was mostly playing a strat through a Pro Reverb. I never dug compressors on guitar before, but what I found was that I could play lead with less distortion, get more tone and just as much sustain. Sweet!

cdog · 1st September 2005, 09:45 PM

Tube amps compress enough for me....

I'm down to "just the basics:"

PEDALBOARD 1
Z Vex Super Duper
Stephenson Stage Hog
Teese RMC1 Wah
EH Wiggler
EH Tube Zipper
EH Electric Mistress
Boss OC2

PEDALBOARD 2

Digitech Wammy
SE Phaser
SE Filter
SE Chaos
EH Stereo Polychorus
Foxrox Paradox TZF
Line 6 Echo Park

DonPedro · 1st September 2005, 09:50 PM

The T-Rex CompNova is unbelievably good at compressing without destroying your sound and killing your dynamics. Keeley is great as well. These 2 rule the comp pedal market in my opinion, transparent and well constructed. My CompNova will never leave my signal path.

Check it out here

audioez · 2nd September 2005, 01:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by retropete

I love my Keeley Compressor.

don't own one but the Keeley kicks arse!!!

The Maxxon Compressor should get mention as well

feyshay · 2nd September 2005, 04:51 AM

Thanks for all the suggestions. I will keep them in mind. It looks like Keeley, Menatone and Carl Martin are all good picks.
I was messing around with this Line 6 Constrictor. I have more of an acoustic background and am pretty new to electric. I've understood compression when it comes to mixing and mastering, but am having a difficult time appreciate the use for the electric guitar.
My impression (and maybe this is just a limitation of this Line 6 pedal) is that the sound is flattened and louder. The Line 6 seems to color the sound depending on which setting you have it (Mellow, Squeeze, or Compact). I'm sure it is in the same ballpark as the Boss CS-3 and MXR dynacomp (having now tried them). Maybe even a little better for tonal variation.
I don't understand the value of compression, considering I seem to be getting a pretty rich tone with my LP and Super Reverb. It seems to diminish rather than add to the sound. (It does seem to cover up my mistakes, though.)

guitarbth · 3rd September 2005, 05:06 PM

When I think compression on guitar, I think of the Edge... particularly the strat, delay, and compressor set up..."Where The Streets Have No Name." I dont like compression in pedals uless it's a strat. But that's just me. For that I use an MXR Supercomp. It sounds good. The Keely and others mentioned may be a tad better, but I'd rather compress recorded signal with outboard unless, again, if its a strat type guitar. The MXR Supercomp is almost exactly like the Dynacomp except it has an attack control. Its like $70 I think... For outboard compression on electrics I'm liking the RNC. I like it better than my 160VU on that particular task.

Brandon

s00p3rm4n · 5th September 2005, 10:38 PM

A wonderful compressor at an

affordable price - Guyatone ST2.

doorknocker · 5th September 2005, 11:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by feyshay

I don't understand the value of compression, considering I seem to be getting a pretty rich tone with my LP and Super Reverb. It seems to diminish rather than add to the sound. (It does seem to cover up my mistakes, though.)

So why do you 'need' one?

pan60 · 6th September 2005, 12:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by doorknocker

So why do you 'need' one?

neve1073 · 6th September 2005, 01:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by feyshay

Thanks for all the suggestions. I will keep them in mind. It looks like Keeley, Menatone and Carl Martin are all good picks.
I was messing around with this Line 6 Constrictor. I have more of an acoustic background and am pretty new to electric. I've understood compression when it comes to mixing and mastering, but am having a difficult time appreciate the use for the electric guitar.
My impression (and maybe this is just a limitation of this Line 6 pedal) is that the sound is flattened and louder. The Line 6 seems to color the sound depending on which setting you have it (Mellow, Squeeze, or Compact). I'm sure it is in the same ballpark as the Boss CS-3 and MXR dynacomp (having now tried them). Maybe even a little better for tonal variation.
I don't understand the value of compression, considering I seem to be getting a pretty rich tone with my LP and Super Reverb. It seems to diminish rather than add to the sound. (It does seem to cover up my mistakes, though.)

Stomp box compressors for guitar usually do more harm than good imo regardless of brand. Skip it unless you know the sound you want and unless the compressor is part of that sound.

Faderjockey · 6th September 2005, 06:07 AM

I like the Barber Electronics Tone Press the best..I use it live and in my studio.
Dave made that thing with a blend knob..It allows you to add the attack back in and it just takes the note and holds on to it. Unlike the Boss style that clamp the first note way to hard.

The Tone Press will sound natural..It sounds uncompressed except it holds the note where you want it. Also works great on bass. I know guys use it on Bass live. I even used it once on bass durning a mix and it was very cool.

I told Dave long ago about the Blend knob being something I wanted in a 2ch rack unit for DAW work...Be nice back before we had ADC in DAW's to have a blend knob for mixing the Dry/Wet compression.

Go check it out while your checking the others out.. http://www.barberelectronics.com/

retropete · 6th September 2005, 03:50 PM

"I'm sure it is in the same ballpark as the Boss CS-3 and MXR dynacomp (having now tried them)."

"I don't understand the value of compression, considering I seem to be getting a pretty rich tone with my LP and Super Reverb."

-- feyshey

I had a Boss compressor, and I agreed at the time with the above statements. But the Keeley is an audiophile compressor and brings out incredible detail in your tone and playing. My jaw dropped when I tried it, it is that spectacular. But I was using it with a strat, and I just loved what it did for my sustain. A Les Paul is a different story. But I can imagine for blues, it would let you milk every nuance. Plus you would be able to get that sustain with little or no distortion. Mucho tone, senor!

P

Randall · 6th September 2005, 04:46 PM

I us the Boss CE-3 myself.. mostly with my Tele and the Fender Deville.. If your doing any "chicken pickin"

it would be pretty hard to function without a healthy dose of compression in the signal chain

feyshay · 6th September 2005, 11:32 PM

Chicken pickin'. Exactly. I've experimented further with the Line 6 compressor and understand the potential utility and limitation of a compressor. I don't need a compressor. I want one to increase options for tone and sustain.

I've ordered the Carl Martin to check out the difference and may consider adding the Guyatone or Keeley to the audition.
Thanks for all the good feedback.
Let me now go spend more money on something meaningless.

PhilE · 7th September 2005, 10:55 AM

MXR,
ROSS, (NOT Boss!!)
or Electro Harmonix do an interesting looking valve one.

Stay analogue in your guitar path wherever posible... especially if using a valve amp.

rodhmos · 7th September 2005, 09:14 PM

I love the Carl Martin compressor. And not only on guitar!

Meriphew · 7th September 2005, 11:55 PM

I have both a Keeley compressor and a Boss CS-2 compressor on my pedalboard. I use the Boss when I need a bit more 'color', and the Keeley when I need more transparent compression. I hardly use either. I've thought about selling them, but I've learned from the past to never sell my toys.

pan60 · 8th September 2005, 12:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Meriphew

but I've learned from the past to never sell my toys.

never, never, never, never!

Ruudman · 8th September 2005, 08:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JMURRAY16

The Carl Martin Compressor is a good unit, but there are better units out there now.

Better is not the word. We all have different taste.

I did a shoot on comps a while ago. Included were pedals like
CM compressor, Analog Man Bi-comprossor and Juicer, Pedalworx McSqueeze
and more.

I found Carl Martin to be the most versatile, but the Juicer had some mojo.
The Bi-comprossor was a bit of a let down.

I went with Carl Martin, and I don't regret it.

ruudman

pan60 · 8th September 2005, 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ruudman

Better is not the word. We all have different taste.
I found Carl Martin to be the most versatile
I went with Carl Martin, and I don't regret it.
ruudman

i have seen no other as versatile.

feyshay · 8th September 2005, 04:54 PM

can't wait for the Carl Martin compressor to try out. I gotta say this electric guitar stuff is a lot more gadgety than the acoustic guitar stuff I'm used to. A lot of fun actually.
Now, how 'bout an equalizer pedal. The MXR M108 looks to be better than the Boss 7 band.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
What is this? anyone seen this pedal before	hrn	So much gear, so little time!	2	2nd April 2007 11:59 AM
Compressor pedal with a really fast attack	CDP	So much gear, so little time!	21	28th November 2005 09:24 PM
Compressor pedal for country/rock'n'roll	preben	So much gear, so little time!	31	13th July 2005 09:57 PM

1st September 2005, 05:59 PM	#1
feyshay Lives for gear Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 1,271	compressor pedal I need a compressor pedal. I know this is not necessarily the best thing for my Fender Super Reverb, taking away the dynamics, but I want one anyway. I decided to try out the Line 6 Constrictor and bought it to mess around with, knowing I can return it in 30 days. What I'm wondering is would it be worth getting something twice the price like the Carl Martin Compressor/Limiter, which gives more control over the variables. Also note that I plan on getting a good compressor/equalizer (probably the Toft EC-1/ or ATC-2 or Joe Meek's One or Two Q) in the future. Would it be worth ordering the Carl Martin from a company in order to try out. Will it make a big difference. Of note, I play a Les Paul Standard. Thanks for any and all suggestions.

1st September 2005, 06:39 PM	#2
pan60 500 series nutjob Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: 500 series Guru SKANK! ; ) Posts: 6,237	i have tried a few, and used a older MXR dyna comp for some time. when i plugged into the Carl Martin Compressor i bought it. i like the control, and it dose not have that drastic sag or pump some have. it dose squeeze a lot, i do wish the compression was not so drastic up front, when you first turn the comp knob you get a lot of compression, but it is the sweetest compressor i have seen in a stomp box. it has become a mainstay for me. i play a G&L ASAT Classic and mostly older fender amps, ( so you have a reference ). i have become a fan of Carl Martin products as a result, and picked up a few more of their box's, before my Carl Martin Compressor i had not found a stomp box i was will to use regularly. __________________ www.pan60.com A CHARTER MEMBER OF THE LA, MAFIA where is LA? IF YOU ARE NOT INTO THE 500 FORMAT, THEN YOU'RE JUST JEALOUS! quote: your secret identity is safe with me superman! Peter Montessi it is easy to sound as though one was endowed with great intelligence, whilst speaking amongst a crowd of total morons

1st September 2005, 06:50 PM	#3
sonic dogg Gear addict Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: pacific northwest Posts: 481	The Carl Martin is the best. I love the 'busy' light... __________________ the clubhouse studio....home of drool'n dogg rekords

1st September 2005, 07:40 PM	#5
feyshay Lives for gear Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 1,271	follow-up Anybody try the Line 6? I know it just came out recently. Don't the pickups on the Les Paul run pretty hot? I always have to keep my volume knobs down to about 4 when I use pedals. Should that be a factor in the decision as to which compressor pedal I go with? I was on the Keeley and analogman pages before and was intrigued, especially by the Comprosser. A couple hundred is a lot for a compressor pedal, no?

1st September 2005, 07:30 PM	#4
JMURRAY16 Gear Head Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 60	The Carl Martin Compressor is a good unit, but there are better units out there now. Firstly, the Keeley Compressor - terrific. Next the Analogman Compressor - Analog Mike always makes great stuff. I even like the Menatone unit a bit better on guitar. Any other questions please let me know.

1st September 2005, 08:40 PM	#6
Amplove Gear maniac Join Date: Apr 2005 Posts: 274	menatone Menatone makes a compressor pedal for guitar that's based on an 1176! That's pretty bitchen. Black Dog anyone? j.

1st September 2005, 09:06 PM	#7
neve1073 Lives for gear Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 1,211	I sometimes use a boss compressor pedal with 65 super reverb. The mxr dynacomp is very good too of course. For a certain squishy sound you need a compressor. But I have mixed feelings about compressor pedals. If I have one in my rack I will use it (on a gig) constantly with subtle settings, but for the music I play I'm pretty sure it sounds better w/o. I know that doesn't make sense which is why I usually don't put a compressor in my pedalboard anymore. It all depends what sound you are going for. I haven't tried the many other compressor pedals. __________________ =================== "Let's be discrete"

1st September 2005, 09:15 PM	#8
TAVD Lives for gear Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Maryland Posts: 1,068	Here's a few more to check out: Barber tone press Demeter compulator Aphex punch factory Janglebox EH Blackfinger or Whitefinger And my fav, the HBE compressor.

1st September 2005, 09:15 PM	#9
retropete Gear addict Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Hoboken, NJ Posts: 387	I love my Keeley Compressor. When I got it, I was mostly playing a strat through a Pro Reverb. I never dug compressors on guitar before, but what I found was that I could play lead with less distortion, get more tone and just as much sustain. Sweet!

1st September 2005, 09:45 PM	#10
cdog Lives for gear Join Date: Dec 2003 Location: Brooklyn Posts: 2,219	Tube amps compress enough for me.... I'm down to "just the basics:" PEDALBOARD 1 Z Vex Super Duper Stephenson Stage Hog Teese RMC1 Wah EH Wiggler EH Tube Zipper EH Electric Mistress Boss OC2 PEDALBOARD 2 Digitech Wammy SE Phaser SE Filter SE Chaos EH Stereo Polychorus Foxrox Paradox TZF Line 6 Echo Park

1st September 2005, 09:50 PM	#11
DonPedro Gear maniac Join Date: Aug 2005 Location: Iceland Posts: 272	The T-Rex CompNova is unbelievably good at compressing without destroying your sound and killing your dynamics. Keeley is great as well. These 2 rule the comp pedal market in my opinion, transparent and well constructed. My CompNova will never leave my signal path. Check it out here

2nd September 2005, 04:51 AM	#13
feyshay Lives for gear Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 1,271	hmm Thanks for all the suggestions. I will keep them in mind. It looks like Keeley, Menatone and Carl Martin are all good picks. I was messing around with this Line 6 Constrictor. I have more of an acoustic background and am pretty new to electric. I've understood compression when it comes to mixing and mastering, but am having a difficult time appreciate the use for the electric guitar. My impression (and maybe this is just a limitation of this Line 6 pedal) is that the sound is flattened and louder. The Line 6 seems to color the sound depending on which setting you have it (Mellow, Squeeze, or Compact). I'm sure it is in the same ballpark as the Boss CS-3 and MXR dynacomp (having now tried them). Maybe even a little better for tonal variation. I don't understand the value of compression, considering I seem to be getting a pretty rich tone with my LP and Super Reverb. It seems to diminish rather than add to the sound. (It does seem to cover up my mistakes, though.)

3rd September 2005, 05:06 PM	#14
guitarbth Gear maniac Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Nashville, TN Posts: 150	When I think compression on guitar, I think of the Edge... particularly the strat, delay, and compressor set up..."Where The Streets Have No Name." I dont like compression in pedals uless it's a strat. But that's just me. For that I use an MXR Supercomp. It sounds good. The Keely and others mentioned may be a tad better, but I'd rather compress recorded signal with outboard unless, again, if its a strat type guitar. The MXR Supercomp is almost exactly like the Dynacomp except it has an attack control. Its like $70 I think... For outboard compression on electrics I'm liking the RNC. I like it better than my 160VU on that particular task. Brandon

5th September 2005, 10:38 PM	#15
s00p3rm4n Gear addict Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: Los Angeles, CA Posts: 318	A wonderful compressor at an affordable price - Guyatone ST2.

6th September 2005, 06:07 AM	#19
Faderjockey Lives for gear Join Date: Aug 2002 Location: B-more Posts: 939	TONE PRESS vote! I like the Barber Electronics Tone Press the best..I use it live and in my studio. Dave made that thing with a blend knob..It allows you to add the attack back in and it just takes the note and holds on to it. Unlike the Boss style that clamp the first note way to hard. The Tone Press will sound natural..It sounds uncompressed except it holds the note where you want it. Also works great on bass. I know guys use it on Bass live. I even used it once on bass durning a mix and it was very cool. I told Dave long ago about the Blend knob being something I wanted in a 2ch rack unit for DAW work...Be nice back before we had ADC in DAW's to have a blend knob for mixing the Dry/Wet compression. Go check it out while your checking the others out.. http://www.barberelectronics.com/

6th September 2005, 03:50 PM	#20
retropete Gear addict Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Hoboken, NJ Posts: 387	"I'm sure it is in the same ballpark as the Boss CS-3 and MXR dynacomp (having now tried them)." "I don't understand the value of compression, considering I seem to be getting a pretty rich tone with my LP and Super Reverb." -- feyshey I had a Boss compressor, and I agreed at the time with the above statements. But the Keeley is an audiophile compressor and brings out incredible detail in your tone and playing. My jaw dropped when I tried it, it is that spectacular. But I was using it with a strat, and I just loved what it did for my sustain. A Les Paul is a different story. But I can imagine for blues, it would let you milk every nuance. Plus you would be able to get that sustain with little or no distortion. Mucho tone, senor! P

6th September 2005, 04:46 PM	#21
Randall Lives for gear Join Date: Jul 2003 Location: Muscle Shoals Posts: 4,064	I us the Boss CE-3 myself.. mostly with my Tele and the Fender Deville.. If your doing any "chicken pickin" it would be pretty hard to function without a healthy dose of compression in the signal chain

6th September 2005, 11:32 PM	#22
feyshay Lives for gear Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 1,271	need versus want Chicken pickin'. Exactly. I've experimented further with the Line 6 compressor and understand the potential utility and limitation of a compressor. I don't need a compressor. I want one to increase options for tone and sustain. I've ordered the Carl Martin to check out the difference and may consider adding the Guyatone or Keeley to the audition. Thanks for all the good feedback. Let me now go spend more money on something meaningless.

7th September 2005, 10:55 AM	#23
PhilE Lives for gear Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: UK Posts: 1,213	MXR, ROSS, (NOT Boss!!) or Electro Harmonix do an interesting looking valve one. Stay analogue in your guitar path wherever posible... especially if using a valve amp.

7th September 2005, 09:14 PM	#24
rodhmos Gear maniac Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 188	I love the Carl Martin compressor. And not only on guitar!

7th September 2005, 11:55 PM	#25
Meriphew Lives for gear Join Date: Sep 2002 Location: Seattle USA Posts: 2,241	I have both a Keeley compressor and a Boss CS-2 compressor on my pedalboard. I use the Boss when I need a bit more 'color', and the Keeley when I need more transparent compression. I hardly use either. I've thought about selling them, but I've learned from the past to never sell my toys. __________________ www.myspace.com/meriphew

8th September 2005, 04:54 PM	#29
feyshay Lives for gear Join Date: Aug 2005 Posts: 1,271	can't wait can't wait for the Carl Martin compressor to try out. I gotta say this electric guitar stuff is a lot more gadgety than the acoustic guitar stuff I'm used to. A lot of fun actually. Now, how 'bout an equalizer pedal. The MXR M108 looks to be better than the Boss 7 band.