Less of a good thing...or more of a mediocre?

[gutsofgold]

Here is my current big, life altering decision.

I can either upgrade my drum mics in a way that would allow me to close mic all of the components of the drum kit but with mediocre, middle of the road mics.

OR

I can get say three decent mics (for example on small diaphram condenser, one large, and a ribbon) and use just those three strategically around the kit.

What would you do?

[soundawg]

My thoughts are... this question is answered by the quality of sound in the room.

If the room sucks or is lacking in some way... go for the close micing - but be selective with your mic choices. If this is mostly for your own kit, take a day out to rent the mics in your budget and do a shootout, pick the ones you like best.

Hell, might as well rent the 'room mic option' also - that way you will really know.

Soundawg

[Benmrx]

IMHO I'd go for a stereo pair of decent LDC mics (not really sure what your budget is), and a good versatile dynamic. If you've got a small room, just place your LDC's lower on the kit, a bit more aimed at the toms.

All in all, I'd say get fewer good mics, as opposed to a bunch of middle of the road ones. Think of it as a gear upgrade, and somewhat of an investment. You'de probably just end up selling those mediocre mics later anyways.