OH Placement

BackHand · 5th May 2006

I have this returning problem with my miking technique of a traditional Rock drumset in my studio.
I want a big roomy sound, especially for the snare so it sounds big pop/rock in style and not so small and dry and in trying to achieve this I always mix my två A/B OH mics way to loud so the cymbals almost pop out of the speakers.

Here is an example of a recording I did recently:

******//www.studio24.nu/ljud/Only_One.mp3

How should I place my OH mics to get away from the cymbals too loud problem?

Should I try to lower the cymbals and also put the mics a little bit behind the kit pointing down at the snare and toms or a little in front of the kit pointing of axis of the cymbals at the snare ?

Any tips? Or should I use two ribbon mics like the Sontronics SIGMA who doesn't have a lot of top end to get the voulme of the cymbals away?

Help

?

seaneldon · 5th May 2006

is the drummer maybe hitting the cymbals too hard in relation to the drums? physically raise the cymbals up from the drums as high as possible without the drummer being uncomfortable. that would help overall cymbal volume more than most mic placements would. other than that, it helps to think about placing the mics in a manner that gets more of the DRUMS, and not so much the cymbals.

BackHand · 5th May 2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by seaneldon

is the drummer maybe hitting the cymbals too hard in relation to the drums? physically raise the cymbals up from the drums as high as possible without the drummer being uncomfortable. that would help overall cymbal volume more than most mic placements would. other than that, it helps to think about placing the mics in a manner that gets more of the DRUMS, and not so much the cymbals.

Should I raise the cymbals towards the OH mics? That should make the cymbals louder?

seaneldon · 5th May 2006

it makes it more difficult for the drummer to smash the shit out of the cymbals. raise your mics, too, if you feel it's necessary, but it's more from the actual playing perspective.

BackHand · 5th May 2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by seaneldon

it makes it more difficult for the drummer to smash the shit out of the cymbals. raise your mics, too, if you feel it's necessary, but it's more from the actual playing perspective.

Hmm.....I'll try that then...any other stuff?

Jason Poulin · 5th May 2006

Really, the cymbals thing is mostly going to be the drummer that will control it.

A drummer can make an overhead in XY sound like a completely mixed drum sound. with the exeption of the kick drum.

I think you should try either XY or spaced pair technique but make sure you can spare a mic to capture a mono or stereo room signal.

Good heavy compression on that mic is always great sounding... especially with a slow release to really ehance that live feel to it. This is were a Distressor on Nuke ratio will kick some ass!!!

As for cymbals... ribbon overheads will help... treated drum room will help alot, 703 broadband absorbtion on walls and ceiling.

Gated room mic is cool too....

If you want big, you have to think big... a nice drum plate rev can enhance this too.

Good luck

Jason

u b k · 6th May 2006

if you want a big room sound, you would do well to dedicate a mic to capturing the room itself. maybe point the mic away from the kit. a little bit of that mic, compressed and blended with overs, should give you what you're after.

also, this is yet another golden application for the transient designer.

gregoire
del ubik

AdamJay · 7th May 2006

you may also want to look into using the recorderman technique (aka modified spaced pair).

This will center and bring forward the snare, and also allow your drummer to beat the hell out of the cymbals and not ruin the OH sound.

kungfugeek · 7th May 2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamJay

you may also want to look into using the recorderman technique (aka modified spaced pair).

This will center and bring forward the snare, and also allow your drummer to beat the hell out of the cymbals and not ruin the OH sound.

I agree, I use this, or XY IN FRONT of the kit if i am getting too much cymbols.

Bishbashbosh · 7th May 2006

Cymbals send sound waves predominantly upwards (if they are hung horizontally).... if you want to capture more kit and less cymbals, you can have the 'oveheads' just in front of the kit, but at cymbal height.
This way you'll get more kit than cymbal.
The Recorderman technique is also great for pushing out the sound of the kick and snare in relation to the rest off the kit.

The suggestion to raise the height of the cymbals is a new one on me. To be honest I'm not convinced by the theory that it makes drummers play them less hard..... but it will make the drummer play less in time.....
A crash cymbal hit at 80% maximum will create sound at much the same dB level as one hit at 70% or at 90%.... they really do have a pretty small dynamic range until you get significantly quieter.

Most complaints about drummers being too 'cymbal heavy' are much more to do with the weakness of their kick and snare in relation to their cymbals.....rather than the actual volume they are playing their cymbals.

5th May 2006	#1
BackHand Gear nut Joined: Feb 2005 Posts: 92 Thread Starter	OH Placement I have this returning problem with my miking technique of a traditional Rock drumset in my studio. I want a big roomy sound, especially for the snare so it sounds big pop/rock in style and not so small and dry and in trying to achieve this I always mix my två A/B OH mics way to loud so the cymbals almost pop out of the speakers. Here is an example of a recording I did recently: ******//www.studio24.nu/ljud/Only_One.mp3 How should I place my OH mics to get away from the cymbals too loud problem? Should I try to lower the cymbals and also put the mics a little bit behind the kit pointing down at the snare and toms or a little in front of the kit pointing of axis of the cymbals at the snare ? Any tips? Or should I use two ribbon mics like the Sontronics SIGMA who doesn't have a lot of top end to get the voulme of the cymbals away? Help ?

5th May 2006	#6
Jason Poulin Lives for gear Joined: Sep 2003 Location: Sudbury, On. Canada Posts: 1,780	Really, the cymbals thing is mostly going to be the drummer that will control it. A drummer can make an overhead in XY sound like a completely mixed drum sound. with the exeption of the kick drum. I think you should try either XY or spaced pair technique but make sure you can spare a mic to capture a mono or stereo room signal. Good heavy compression on that mic is always great sounding... especially with a slow release to really ehance that live feel to it. This is were a Distressor on Nuke ratio will kick some ass!!! As for cymbals... ribbon overheads will help... treated drum room will help alot, 703 broadband absorbtion on walls and ceiling. Gated room mic is cool too.... If you want big, you have to think big... a nice drum plate rev can enhance this too. Good luck Jason __________________ If it don't sound like a record... don't press record

7th May 2006	#8
AdamJay Lives for gear Joined: Aug 2005 Location: Indianapolis, IN Posts: 2,825	you may also want to look into using the recorderman technique (aka modified spaced pair). This will center and bring forward the snare, and also allow your drummer to beat the hell out of the cymbals and not ruin the OH sound. __________________

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Subwoofer placement	Dopamine	So much gear, so little time!	5	23rd March 2006 05:05 AM
Track Placement	Umlaaat	Rap + Hip Hop engineering & production	6	6th March 2006 10:49 AM
placement for microphone	Pilepoile	So much gear, so little time!	4	7th December 2005 04:01 PM
Subwoofer placement	DivineMusic	So much gear, so little time!	7	31st May 2005 05:12 PM
Mic placement	kroad	So much gear, so little time!	1	18th August 2004 09:03 AM

5th May 2006	#2
seaneldon Lives for gear Joined: Mar 2006 Location: Bahstahn, MA Posts: 2,687	is the drummer maybe hitting the cymbals too hard in relation to the drums? physically raise the cymbals up from the drums as high as possible without the drummer being uncomfortable. that would help overall cymbal volume more than most mic placements would. other than that, it helps to think about placing the mics in a manner that gets more of the DRUMS, and not so much the cymbals.

6th May 2006	#7
u b k Gear Guru Joined: Oct 2004 Location: The Land of Sunshine Posts: 11,290	if you want a big room sound, you would do well to dedicate a mic to capturing the room itself. maybe point the mic away from the kit. a little bit of that mic, compressed and blended with overs, should give you what you're after. also, this is yet another golden application for the transient designer. gregoire del ubik

7th May 2006	#10
Bishbashbosh Lives for gear Joined: Sep 2005 Location: London Posts: 602	Cymbals send sound waves predominantly upwards (if they are hung horizontally).... if you want to capture more kit and less cymbals, you can have the 'oveheads' just in front of the kit, but at cymbal height. This way you'll get more kit than cymbal. The Recorderman technique is also great for pushing out the sound of the kick and snare in relation to the rest off the kit. The suggestion to raise the height of the cymbals is a new one on me. To be honest I'm not convinced by the theory that it makes drummers play them less hard..... but it will make the drummer play less in time..... A crash cymbal hit at 80% maximum will create sound at much the same dB level as one hit at 70% or at 90%.... they really do have a pretty small dynamic range until you get significantly quieter. Most complaints about drummers being too 'cymbal heavy' are much more to do with the weakness of their kick and snare in relation to their cymbals.....rather than the actual volume they are playing their cymbals.