Quote:
Originally Posted by MX582  im only 17 and ive been using digital so far but i can definatly see why tapes were so badass..as soon as i get the oportunity im getting a tape machine
digital and all these plug ins = 
analog = thumbsup |
With the good comes the bad...
- tape reels that are expensive and short on time.
- waiting around while striping tapes.
- aligning/calibrating heads.
- demagnetizing heads.
- lots of moving parts to wear out and break down (plus, finding the parts... if you can, and the cost to replace them).
Generally, a lot of maintenance involved with analog tape machines. Digital and analog both have their ups and downs. Digital has come a long way and certainly isn't "Deth". Anything can be good if you learn how to use it properly.
---
Back on topic, I think it's impossible to answer this question (though there are many great attempts here). Too subjective... as are most things of this nature.
I agree on the record by record basis comment... what's the best for a given song might not work elsewhere... so it caan't really be the best. The tones on tape (unless you've heard them solo) are very much influenced by the overall mix, accompanying instrumentation and attitude/feel/playing of the musicians as well.
I think the question would be better worded as "Which taped guitar tone would you say made a specific song/album?" as shown by most of the responses thus far.
---
c