First, thanks to everyone for the collective input. Believe me when I say I've read everything 5 times!
Here's the current plan (without specifying EQ and compressor choices):
Snare > SM57 > ISA428
Kick > ATM25 > ISA 428
Overhead Left > MXL 603S > RNP
Overhead Right > MXL 603S > RNP
Room (Mono) > AT4047 > ISA 428
Beyond that, I'll leave it to the drummer, mic positioning and my ears. I have about half the pieces I need and I'm tracking the rest down over the next week or so.
-Synth80s