Gearslutz.com - View Single Post - So, how do you all reconcile the fact...
View Single Post
Old 4th September 2010   #149
mhs2xs
Lives for gear
 
mhs2xs's Avatar
 
Joined: May 2010
Location: Island Swamp, MS
Posts: 1,120

Quote:
Originally Posted by blue nine View Post
pretty soon slowing to a halt... YTY YTD #'s are down another 12% first six mos of 2010 vs first six mos 2009...

Can I ask what you actually do in the industry? Do you have a band? Do management? Work at a studio or label?

guess what started happening en mass in 1999...

Music's lost decade: Sales cut in half in 2000s - Feb. 2, 2010



the promise of the internet is size and scale

this is what the proponents of micro economics and internet flat tax surcharges promote and it should have worked for recorded music.

alot of people have pointed to the transition from albums to individual songs as being the cause of reduced revenue for the record industry

I understand where on the surface one could make this argument, however... it should follow the argument made by the pricing proponents

in 1999 in the USA there were probably 10 thousand retail points of sale for physical music, tower, sam goody, target, walmart, etc.

at the time they were selling $20 dollar physical discs - much of the overhead due to physical packaging, manufacturing, shipping and stocking fees.

these physical retail locations had all the problems of supply side inventory management - a band would be on tour, and no stock would be in that market, a song would be played on the radio and the album would quickly be out of stock, etc. a tv show or commercial features a song and suddenly there is demand, but no availability.

these supply side inventory issues combined with limited points of sale were a massive problem for the record industry. digital distribution has none of these problem.

today someone can walk from their living room to their computer (or it may be on their lap) to order the latest hot song, featured in Gossip Girl.

so today in 2010 there are an estimated 500 million* retail points of sale for prerecorded music via itunes alone.
*500 Million_Active_Itunes_Users

just stop and think about this for a second... we went from 10 thousand points of sale to 500 Million points of sale in less than a decade and removed all of the supply side inventory issues... wow.

the promise, size and scale of the internet should have seen sales of pre-recorded music increase, massively...

there is frequent argument made that if music cost less, it would sell more... well, we now have 99 cent songs and 9.99 albums and sales have dropped by half in a decade...

so the industry removed inventory problems, made music instantly available, allowed for songs to be sold individually at a price never before possible and dropped the price of the album by half of the retail list price of a decade ago...

but we didn't and haven't seen sales increase (or even flatline) because at the same time, the same product and service is offered for illegally, for free, and without consequence.

this also illustrates these issues:



others would like to make the point that 99 cent songs and 9.99 albums are the cause of reduced revenue - the reasoning being, Lower Prices = Lower Revenue, but this isn't true either...

actually the margin on a 9.99 album download is about the same as a 19.99 CD... due to there being reduced, or removed manufacturing, shipping and distribution fees as well as there being no returns reserves (30% in and of itself on average).

what we're actually seeing is not a drop in revenue from reduced pricing, but more so the decline in overall album unit sales even when factoring album equivalent song downloads.

so in reality it is an overall decline in album unit sales (and again this factoring in album equivalent song downloads).

so these assumptions appear to be incorrect.

even when talking about "singles sales" physical singles contained 2-4 songs depending on format (vinyl, cd, cs) and retailed for about $2 - $4, which like other physical mediums much of that price went off the top to manufacturing, shipping and distribution fees as well as there being no returns reserves (30% in and of itself on average).

So ultimately there is more per unit margin on digital songs, than there ever was on physical "Singles"

2009 Sales Wrap: Transactions Up As Digital Growth Slows

although this decline in over all units is certainly represented in lost revenue... less units, less revenue... simple... and it's been going on that way for about a decade...
Some think "a profit" is enough to stay in business, but in today's climate (especially with the HUGE tax hikes that are about to hit, yeah, get those "rich" record label owners) but when a business is bleeding due to loss of sales from theft, as EFF illustrated here, and then has the additional tax burden, it's not going to be long before that business is no more.

EFF, did you major or minor in econ or something? Or is this just a hobby based in self preservation?

Cheers!
Mitchell
mhs2xs is offline