| Too me it sounds pretty good.
I think regarding atmos it's not the question if it's good enough but the question where and how you use it. It's all the "noises" in the end.
Since it's a mono recording it usualy will/may be paired with some stereo or surround atmoses. May be there is some hiss and at the same time some lack of high frequency. But again, thats okay when you use it together with other BG.
However this track may be the one you want to use in certain situation.
Was it recorded with MKH416 or 60?
I often prefer atmos recorded with good omni's mics, though MS may sound very well too.
I always take my Sony PCM-D1 in mybackpack with me whereever I go.
And when I hear it in the studio and compare the quality or recordins made with my DPA Omni's or MKH8020 pair or some MS (MKH 30/60) I did...well it's difficult to compare.
But I often found myself using PCM-D1 recording in the sessions demanding this specific sounds.
So for me it's not only the question of quality but more about the traget it should achieve. |