Quote:
Originally Posted by allencollins  import a 24+ track project into mutliple DAW's, Mixdown in REALTIME not BOUNCE
but playback the 24tracks in REALTIME to a 2 track system of some sort with all the daws. Seriously just do it |
Quote:
Originally Posted by peeder If someone provides me with a test suite and the ability to run the tests on various DAWs to see if there is a difference I will attempt to reproduce their results. |
"Seriously just do it?"
Seriously? Just did it. Four years ago. Want to read the test methodology? It's here:
The Rules for Testing - 3dB
(I don't think you'll read it, because I posted links to discussion about that project before in this thread. Your responses clearly indicate you have not read it. But if you do, you'll see that what you're proposing has already been done. Instead of suggesting someone reproduce a test that has already been done, why don't you look at the conclusions?)
If you don't like the results that we found four years ago, please conduct your own test. I'll be interested to see if your results confirm ours.
To be honest, there were only 22 tracks (11 stereo pairs), and the method of compiling them down to stereo was not specified.
Realtime, not bounce? Your reasoning? Now we've moved past the summing myth and we're onto the bounce myth? I addressed that one as well, but that was more like 6 years ago.
I've spent a lot of time and energy trying to figure out what is doing what. And trying to find out why things sound different. And IF they really sound different or if we're fooling ourselves. (It happens far more than any of us would care to admit.)
What exactly is it you're trying to prove?