Quote:
Originally Posted by Tony Shepperd  You say no Pro Tools in your studio and yet you have Pro Tools LE.
I have been in your studio many times. GREAT ROOM!
But it is built as composers room, not geared for heavy duty tracking. |
As you know, we record orchestra a few times a year. I own Pro Tools LE so that I can transfer tracks out of PT and into Logic so I can edit and mix them there. I prefer Logic's sound and environment.
I have no doubt that there are many studios doing "heavy tracking" with native systems. I don't think it's at all realistic to think that PT is the only viable and working solution for that application. There are many other solutions, all of them viable, being put to use every day.
Quote:
But do you honestly believe that Logic 8 is the HD killer?
If that is the case, I would imagine then there will be a ton of HD systems on the market in the next week or so.
|
I'm not sure why this thread is focusing on L8 as a "Pro Tools killer?" I personally haven't heard it to be that, and as I mentioned in my original post, I'm not looking for Logic in any way to be more like PT. Why change it when those who prefer PT can simply steer clear of Logic and use PT? It doesn't -- and won't kill PT. The same goes for PT -- it will never replace Logic no matter what Digi implements. This is a silly contest that will never be won.
Quote:
As for the sonics, you and I have sat in on listening test before that various friends of ours have managed to easily pick out Pro Tools mix over Logic.
There is a difference.
|
Different, yes. Better, no. Picking out a mix by Pro Tools users who are intimately familiar with the sound of their DAW is no feat. The same would go for me in a shootout. I would probably be able to pick out a Logic mix. But picking something out blind does not equate to it sounding better. In the end, as with all things DAW related, it will continue to be simply personal preference. And that's fine. But as I mentioned before, the comparisons are getting old as there will always be differences between platforms.
Best,
Kaveh
www.kavehcohen.com