View Single Post
Old 27th January 2004, 06:17 PM   #15
jdier
Gear addict
 
jdier's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Wisconsin, US
Posts: 355
Re: Re: Have you, Are you, Should you...Ear Training

Quote:
Originally posted by PlugHead
FWIW,

I have perfect pitch, and tho it can be a curse in many, many ways, it's a godsend for re-arranging voicings, guitar lines, vocal harmonies (in the studio, as well as live performance) etc. Being able to tell players the exact notes rather than singing passages and them attempting to copy/follow can be a big timesaver.

best,
Plug,

I think you are crossing the lines. I know people with perfect pitch who cannot tell a 4th from a 5th. You play a note, they tell you what it is. You play two notes, they can tell you what each is, but cannot tell you the interval.

Your perfect pitch is impressive, but it is your MUSICAL TRAINING and KNOWLEDGE which enables you to effectively re-arrange voicings, guitar lines, and vocal harmonies... Your perfect pitch plays less of a role than your musical training in these cases

(in my opinion)

Jim
jdier is offline   Reply With Quote